Summary
- Islamabad: Serious questions over the implementation of Balochistan’s federal job quota and the possible damage caused by major dam projects have emerged after a Senate subcommittee was informed that complete recruitment records were unavailable, while 72 traditional underground water channels in Panjgur had already been affected by changes in water extraction.
- The committee demanded full details of 5,000 government posts earmarked for Balochistan and expressed concern over proposed dam designs that could threaten agricultural land, thousands of date palm trees and traditional irrigation systems supporting local communities.
- The Project Director informed the committee that Panjgur Dam had been designed to provide irrigation water to approximately 25,000 acres of land.
Islamabad: Serious questions over the implementation of Balochistan’s federal job quota and the possible damage caused by major dam projects have emerged after a Senate subcommittee was informed that complete recruitment records were unavailable, while 72 traditional underground water channels in Panjgur had already been affected by changes in water extraction.
The committee demanded full details of 5,000 government posts earmarked for Balochistan and expressed concern over proposed dam designs that could threaten agricultural land, thousands of date palm trees and traditional irrigation systems supporting local communities.
The issues came under discussion during a meeting of the Senate subcommittee on Problems of Less Developed Areas, chaired by Senator Jan Muhammad Buledi at Parliament House on November 17, 2026.
The committee reviewed the implementation of the Aghaz e Huqooq e Balochistan Package, ongoing development projects and the province’s employment quota in federal ministries, divisions, attached departments and autonomous bodies.
A major concern emerged when the Secretary Establishment Division informed the committee that available records of appointments made against Balochistan’s quota in federal institutions were neither clear nor complete.
Officials said the relevant data was being compiled again in accordance with the Prime Minister’s instructions.
Senator Jan Muhammad Buledi expressed dissatisfaction over the absence of complete information regarding sanctioned posts, existing appointments, vacant positions and jobs reserved for candidates from Balochistan.
He directed the Establishment Division to submit a detailed comparative report showing appointments, vacancies and quota allocations separately for Grade 1 to 5 and Grade 6 to 16 positions.
The committee particularly demanded complete details of 5,000 posts reserved for Balochistan, raising questions about how the implementation of the provincial quota could be properly assessed without reliable recruitment records.
The chairman emphasized that Balochistan must receive its rightful share of federal employment opportunities in accordance with the applicable quota arrangements.
Another administrative concern involved provincial officers who had remained posted in federal institutions on deputation for unusually long periods.
Officials informed the committee that some officers from Balochistan had served in federal departments for 10 to 14 years.
These included professors, lecturers and subject specialists from the provincial education department.
According to the briefing, their prolonged absence affected recruitment against vacant posts in provincial institutions.
The committee was informed that officers serving on extended deputation had now been returned to their respective provincial departments.
Meanwhile, Federal Minister for Planning, Development and Special Initiatives Ahsan Iqbal told the committee that Balochistan’s development was essential for Pakistan’s overall progress.
He acknowledged that the Public Sector Development Programme was facing serious financial pressure.
According to the minister, development spending under the programme represented 2.6 percent of gross domestic product in 2018, but its share had now fallen to almost negligible levels under difficult financial conditions.
Despite these difficulties, he said approximately Rs 200 billion had been allocated for development projects in Balochistan, an amount he described as higher than the allocation for Punjab.
Ahsan Iqbal also highlighted the importance of the National Highway 25 project, saying its cost would exceed Rs 400 billion.
He stated that the government had set a target of completing the major highway project within two years.
The proposed Panjgur Dam became a major subject of debate after members questioned whether its design adequately protected existing irrigation systems, agricultural land and date orchards.
Senator Jan Muhammad Buledi questioned why the effects on traditional water sources had not been properly assessed before the project was planned.
He stressed that public development funds should improve people’s lives rather than create new difficulties for farmers and residents.
The committee was informed that Panjgur previously had 118 traditional underground water channels, locally known as karez, which supplied irrigation water to approximately 6,000 acres of agricultural land.
According to the Project Director, the growing use of solar powered groundwater extraction systems had affected the traditional irrigation network, with 72 karez already impacted.
He further disclosed that water flow in 34 karez had declined by more than 50 percent during 2025 and 2026.
These figures raised serious concerns about the future of farming and water availability in Panjgur.
The Project Director informed the committee that Panjgur Dam had been designed to provide irrigation water to approximately 25,000 acres of land.
The proposed dam would have a height of 33 metres, with an original canal plan comprising a 30.24 kilometre canal on the left side and a 9.8 kilometre canal on the right.
Committee members expressed concern that open canals could damage date palm trees, farmland and existing irrigation arrangements.
Member of the National Assembly Phulain Baloch emphasized that development projects should protect local livelihoods and agricultural resources.
He also raised questions about differences in the project’s estimated cost and the proposed acquisition of land belonging to local residents.
In response, planning officials informed the committee that the dam’s design would be reviewed and recommendations had been sought from the concerned irrigation department.
The Project Director said the earlier open canal design had been revised in favour of a pipeline system to reduce the possible damage to thousands of date palm trees and agricultural land.
He informed members that the revised design had been finalized, while a financial estimate from China was still awaited to determine the cost of the pipeline system.
Surveys of the affected areas had been completed, although security conditions had delayed survey activities at some locations.
The committee also raised serious questions over the proposed Gish Kaur Dam and its possible effects on downstream agriculture and water supplies reaching Mirani Dam.
Senator Jan Muhammad Buledi questioned the project’s feasibility, claiming that agricultural land linked to the proposed dam did not exist as presented.
He demanded that the feasibility report be submitted at the next committee meeting.
The committee also directed the Water and Power Development Authority (WAPDA) to provide a detailed report explaining how the dam could affect agricultural activities connected with Kech Kaur downstream and how much water reaching Mirani Dam might be reduced.
We welcome your contributions! Submit your blogs, opinion pieces, press releases, news story pitches, and news features to opinion@minutemirror.com.pk and minutemirrormail@gmail.com

