Summary
- A more fundamental alternative deserves national consideration: gradually replacing the provincial tier with constitutionally empowered district governments and elected union councils.
- A district centred federation would make elected district governments the principal institutions of public administration.
- Pakistan must, therefore, compare the full costs and benefits of existing provinces with stronger local governments, additional provinces and a district centred federation.
PAKISTAN is debating how many provinces it needs when it should be asking whether provincial governments, in their present form, remain necessary. Proposals for additional provinces promise administrative efficiency, regional representation and better governance. Still they leave a fundamental contradiction untouched: political authority remains concentrated in provincial capitals while citizens struggle to obtain basic services in their own communities.
Pakistan does not need more provincial capitals. It needs government closer to its citizens.
Creating new provinces could multiply chief ministers, governors, cabinets, assemblies and bureaucratic establishments without improving schools, hospitals, sanitation and access to justice. A more fundamental alternative deserves national consideration: gradually replacing the provincial tier with constitutionally empowered district governments and elected union councils.
This would require a comprehensive reconstruction of Pakistan’s federation. But if public institutions exist to serve citizens rather than perpetuate inherited arrangements of political authority, their structure must remain open to democratic reconsideration.
Pakistan’s provinces reflect complex histories of colonial administration, regional identities and constitutional struggles. They have also provided important protections against excessive federal centralisation. Their abolition must, therefore, never mean suppressing cultural, linguistic and historical identities. These rights belong to communities and citizens, not to provincial bureaucracies.
Ethnic diversity is not Pakistan’s problem. Its political exploitation is.
Regional grievances often emerge from genuine inequalities in representation, development and access to resources. Political elites can convert these grievances into struggles over territorial control, public appointments and financial allocations. Kinship alliances, dynastic politics and patronage networks frequently shape these contests.
New provinces would not necessarily dismantle such relationships. They could reproduce them within smaller territories. Districts neglected by Lahore might eventually experience similar neglect from another provincial capital. The geography of power would change while its social organisation remained intact.
The deeper problem is institutional centralisation, not territorial size.
Pakistan inherited an administrative tradition that prioritised revenue collection, policing and political order. Colonial district administration primarily served the interests of the governing state. Independence established constitutional rights and representative institutions, but significant practices of bureaucratic control survived.
A democratic state must reverse this relationship. Public administration should deliver services rather than compel citizens to navigate distant centres of authority.
A district centred federation would make elected district governments the principal institutions of public administration. District councils and accountable local executives would oversee schools, district healthcare, land administration, local infrastructure and development planning. Elected union councils would manage neighbourhood sanitation, community facilities, local water distribution and the monitoring of essential services.
Citizens should know which institution bears responsibility for a dysfunctional school, an absent doctor or an unrepaired street. They should also know how much public money that institution receives.
Not every function belongs within district boundaries. Universities, specialised hospitals, major transport networks and shared water systems require coordination across larger territories. Democratically supervised regional authorities could manage these services through cooperation among districts. The federation would retain defence, foreign affairs, national economic policy and constitutional safeguards.
The decisive transformation, however, concerns public finance.
Article 160 of the Constitution establishes the National Finance Commission framework for distributing revenues between the federation and provinces. Article 140A requires provinces to devolve political, administrative and financial authority to elected local governments. Yet local institutions remain dependent on provincial decisions concerning their powers, resources and continuity.
A district based federation would replace this dependency with constitutionally guaranteed fiscal transfers. A reconstituted NFC should distribute an agreed share of national revenues directly to district governments, while district finance arrangements should guarantee resources for union councils.
Population alone must not determine these allocations. Poverty, geographical disadvantage, infrastructure deficits and local revenue capacity should also matter. Otherwise, prosperous districts could consolidate their advantages while poorer communities remained dependent on discretionary assistance.
Districts should possess clearly defined local taxation powers, independent financial audits and transparent procurement systems. Every district and union council should publish accessible budgets, expenditure records and service delivery assessments.
However, decentralisation cannot succeed by merely relocating political patronage. Influential families could capture district councils just as they influence provincial assemblies. Regular elections, transparent recruitment, enforceable conflict-of-interest rules and meaningful representation for women and minorities must therefore accompany institutional reform.
Local democracy must not become provincial patronage reproduced on a smaller scale.
The financial argument also requires caution. Abolishing provincial assemblies, cabinets and associated political establishments could eliminate certain expenditures. It would not eliminate the costs of teachers, doctors, police personnel, courts and public infrastructure. These responsibilities would continue under district, federal or interdistrict institutions.
Pakistan must, therefore, compare the full costs and benefits of existing provinces with stronger local governments, additional provinces and a district centred federation. Such an assessment should include transition expenditure, pensions, public assets, administrative coordination and measurable improvements in services.
The objective is not simply cheaper government. It is better government for every rupee spent.
Constitutional feasibility presents another challenge. Provinces are constituent units of Pakistan’s federation, not departments that Parliament can abolish through ordinary legislation. Replacing them would require a new constitutional settlement addressing parliamentary representation, fiscal distribution, judicial authority, regional rights and existing public assets.
Any transformation must emerge through democratic consent and constitutional procedures. It must never transfer provincial authority wholesale to Islamabad. That would merely replace one form of centralisation with another.
An independent constitutional commission should examine district-based federalism alongside less disruptive alternatives. Pakistan could first test substantial district level administrative and fiscal autonomy within the existing framework. Independent evaluation would establish whether such reforms improve public services and whether eliminating provinces offers additional benefits that meaningful devolution cannot achieve.
The debate should ultimately return to the ordinary citizen. A farmer needs accessible land records, not another provincial secretariat. A mother needs a functioning hospital, not another ministerial residence. A student needs a good public school, not another assembly building.
The measure of decentralisation is not the number of capitals a country establishes. It is the authority, resources and accountability that reach its people.
Pakistan has spent decades debating who should control its territories. It is time to determine who will serve its citizens.
We welcome your contributions! Submit your blogs, opinion pieces, press releases, news story pitches, and news features to opinion@minutemirror.com.pk and minutemirrormail@gmail.com

