Summary
- Islamabad: Serious legal questions have emerged over a proposed amendment to Pakistan’s election laws that seeks to transfer certain election appeals from the Supreme Court to the Federal Constitutional Court, with a Senate committee asking the Ministry of Law and Justice and the Election Commission of Pakistan (ECP) to explain the constitutional basis and necessity of the proposed change.
- The Senate Standing Committee on Law and Justice, chaired by Senator Farooq Hamid Naek, questioned why appeals arising under the Elections Act, 2017, should be transferred to the Federal Constitutional Court when they are created by an ordinary law rather than directly under the Constitution.
- The committee sought detailed legal justification from the Law Ministry and ECP, both of which support the proposed amendment.
Islamabad: Serious legal questions have emerged over a proposed amendment to Pakistan’s election laws that seeks to transfer certain election appeals from the Supreme Court to the Federal Constitutional Court, with a Senate committee asking the Ministry of Law and Justice and the Election Commission of Pakistan (ECP) to explain the constitutional basis and necessity of the proposed change.
The Senate Standing Committee on Law and Justice, chaired by Senator Farooq Hamid Naek, questioned why appeals arising under the Elections Act, 2017, should be transferred to the Federal Constitutional Court when they are created by an ordinary law rather than directly under the Constitution.
The committee sought detailed legal justification from the Law Ministry and ECP, both of which support the proposed amendment.
The issue arose during consideration of the Elections (Amendment) Bill, 2026, which seeks to bring the Elections Act, 2017, into line with the constitutional framework introduced through the Constitution (Twenty Seventh Amendment) Act, 2025.
The bill was introduced by Senator Khalil Tahir on his own behalf and on behalf of Senator Mohammad Abdul Qadir during the Senate sitting on October 26, 2026.
The proposed legislation has raised an important question about which court should hear certain appeals involving election matters.
At present, the appeals under discussion fall within the Supreme Court’s jurisdiction. The proposed amendment seeks to move them to the Federal Constitutional Court.
During the meeting, Senator Farooq Hamid Naek specifically referred to Sections 9 and 155 of the Elections Act, 2017.
He observed that the appeals arising under these sections were statutory appeals, meaning they were created through legislation passed by Parliament.
The chairman pointed out that these appeals were different from appeals arising out of proceedings under Article 199 of the Constitution.
He questioned what constitutional or legal grounds justified transferring such appeals to the Federal Constitutional Court.
The distinction became the central issue in the committee’s examination of the proposed legislation.
The chairman sought an explanation of whether the constitutional changes introduced in 2025 provided sufficient legal justification for changing the existing court responsible for hearing these appeals.
He also asked why the Ministry of Law and Justice and the Election Commission of Pakistan supported the proposed transfer.
The committee demanded that both institutions explain the reasons behind their support and clarify how the proposed amendment would affect the existing election appeal process.
Another significant development emerged when the Ministry of Parliamentary Affairs informed the committee that the National Assembly had already passed a separate private member’s bill dealing with the same subject.
The disclosure prompted the committee to demand the complete legislative record.
The committee directed that the bill passed by the National Assembly, along with the report of the relevant National Assembly committee, be placed before it at its next meeting.
These documents would allow the Senate committee to examine the proposed changes alongside the legislation already considered by the National Assembly.
The chairman’s questions have placed the Law Ministry and ECP under pressure to provide clear legal reasoning for their support of the amendment.
However, the committee did not reject the proposed bill or declare the transfer unconstitutional.
Instead, it sought clarification before proceeding further. Senators Shahadat Awan, Khalil Tahir and Mohammad Abdul Qadir attended the meeting.
The committee deferred the remaining agenda items to its next meeting.
We welcome your contributions! Submit your blogs, opinion pieces, press releases, news story pitches, and news features to opinion@minutemirror.com.pk and minutemirrormail@gmail.com

