HEC reports no disciplinary action against law institutions in 5 academic years, cites FIA probe into 32 Colleges

Nadeem Tanoli
By
Nadeem Tanoli
The writer is a journalist based in Islamabad who has been covering parliamentary affairs for the past 15 years. He also reports on health, education, environmental,...
8 Min Read

Summary

  • ISLAMABAD:  Serious questions over illegal admissions, irregular affiliations, questionable attendance records and weak monitoring of law colleges have emerged after the Higher Education Commission (HEC) informed the Pakistan Information Commission that it had taken no specific disciplinary action against institutions during the requested academic period, while acknowledging a Federal Investigation Agency (FIA) investigation involving 32 private law colleges affiliated with Bahauddin Zakariya University, Multan.
  • HEC informed the commission that the Supreme Court of Pakistan had examined allegations involving illegal admissions, admission of students beyond permitted limits, irregular affiliations, questionable attendance records and violations of prescribed requirements.
  • According to HEC, the Supreme Court directed the FIA to investigate alleged irregularities involving 32 private law colleges.
AI Generated Summary

ISLAMABAD:  Serious questions over illegal admissions, irregular affiliations, questionable attendance records and weak monitoring of law colleges have emerged after the Higher Education Commission (HEC) informed the Pakistan Information Commission that it had taken no specific disciplinary action against institutions during the requested academic period, while acknowledging a Federal Investigation Agency (FIA) investigation involving 32 private law colleges affiliated with Bahauddin Zakariya University, Multan.

The disclosure has raised concerns about the protection of students who spend considerable money and years of study at institutions that may later face questions over their affiliation or admission practices.

The information emerged in a written response submitted by HEC on November 11, 2026, in an appeal filed by Munir Ahmad under the Right of Access to Information Act, 2017.

The appeal, numbered 6065/09/2026, concerns information about recognized law institutions, admission limits, college inspections, complaints, regulatory action and safeguards for affected students.

One of the most significant revelations concerns the case of 32 private law colleges affiliated with Bahauddin Zakariya University, Multan.

HEC informed the commission that the Supreme Court of Pakistan had examined allegations involving illegal admissions, admission of students beyond permitted limits, irregular affiliations, questionable attendance records and violations of prescribed requirements.

According to HEC, the Supreme Court directed the FIA to investigate alleged irregularities involving 32 private law colleges.

The HEC stated that the FIA investigation identified serious discrepancies in student admissions and academic records.

It also acknowledged that Bahauddin Zakariya University subsequently initiated action against private law colleges, including cancellation of affiliations, in light of the identified irregularities and directions from the relevant judicial forum.

However, HEC’s response did not provide a complete list of the affected colleges, the number of affiliations cancelled or details of the action taken against each institution.

The records also did not establish that all 32 colleges had been found guilty of wrongdoing.

Another major issue concerns the monitoring of law colleges across Pakistan.

HEC stated that under its revised Institutional Affiliation Policy, 2024, universities and degree awarding institutions are responsible for verifying, monitoring and evaluating their affiliated colleges.

It explicitly stated that HEC does not physically inspect affiliated colleges under this arrangement.

According to the response, the relevant university’s affiliation office and quality enhancement cell are responsible for monitoring, while university registrars and institutional heads have specific duties concerning verification and records.

The disclosure has raised questions about how effective monitoring can be ensured when responsibility is divided among different institutions.

HEC maintained that its responsibility includes regulating higher education standards, recognizing universities and monitoring quality within its legal authority.

It explained that the affiliation of individual law colleges falls under the relevant universities, while the Pakistan Bar Council has responsibilities concerning professional legal education and registration of law degree programmes.

The HEC also provided a list of 75 HEC recognized universities and higher education institutions registered with the Pakistan Bar Council for legal education.

However, it did not provide the complete college wise and year wise affiliation records requested by the applicant.

The information request covered the academic years 2022 to 2023, 2023 to 2024, 2024 to 2025, 2025 to 2026 and 2026 to 2027.

The applicant had sought information on colleges that were recognized, newly affiliated, suspended, disaffiliated, blacklisted or prohibited from admitting students.

Another important issue concerned the number of students allowed to enter law colleges.

HEC stated that it does not prescribe a single nationwide reserved seat quota for LLB admissions.

It explained that some universities apply admission quotas under their own policies, while the Pakistan Bar Council specifies or allocates seats.

The applicant had requested details of approved seats for individual law colleges, along with relevant notifications and orders.

HEC also addressed concerns about the protection of students when action is taken against an affiliated college.

It maintained that the relevant affiliating university is responsible for protecting the academic interests of students already admitted, including arrangements for completing their studies and examinations.

However, the written response did not provide college wise figures showing how many students had been affected by regulatory action or what specific relief had been provided.

The applicant had also requested records of complaints involving alleged unauthorized admissions, unlawful fee collection, misleading claims about recognition and financial or academic losses suffered by students.

HEC referred to the responsibilities of universities and the Pakistan Bar Council rather than providing a detailed nationwide list of such complaints and resulting actions.

Significantly, HEC stated that no specific disciplinary action regarding the institutions had been taken by the commission during the period covered by the request.

This statement concerns action by HEC itself and does not mean that universities, courts or other regulatory authorities took no action.

The HEC also cited regulatory provisions allowing action against institutions involved in unlawful activities, including closure where legally justified.

Another part of the information request concerned the use of Urdu in legal education.

HEC referred to the revised LLB curriculum for 2025, which includes legal drafting and pleadings and aims to equip students with skills for preparing legal documents in Urdu.

However, it did not provide a complete institution wise record of colleges using Urdu as a medium of instruction.

The information request was first submitted to HEC on September 4, 2026, by Munir Ahmad, Senior Advocate High Court, in public interest, citing the hardships faced by youth who have fallen victim to fraudulent schemes and unaffiliated law colleges.

The Pakistan Information Commission received his appeal on September 14 and issued its first notice to HEC on September 18.

At the hearing on October 22, HEC representatives requested additional time to submit their written response, which the commission granted.

On November 11, the commission recorded that HEC had submitted its reply and directed that it be shared with the applicant for any further response.

In a communication dated November 12, the commission gave the applicant 20 days to submit his comments on HEC’s reply.

The proceedings were adjourned until December 15, 2026.

However, the disclosures have brought renewed attention to the regulation of private law colleges, the availability of admission and inspection records, and the responsibility of public institutions to protect students from unauthorized educational practices.

The matter remains before the Pakistan Information Commission, where the applicant has been given an opportunity to respond to HEC’s explanation.

We welcome your contributions! Submit your blogs, opinion pieces, press releases, news story pitches, and news features to opinion@minutemirror.com.pk and minutemirrormail@gmail.com
Share This Article
The writer is a journalist based in Islamabad who has been covering parliamentary affairs for the past 15 years. He also reports on health, education, environmental, and human rights issues. He can be reached at nadeemumer6@gmail.com.
Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *