Summary
- It is a principle for selecting institutions according to their demonstrated capacity to serve human purposes. Competitive enterprise may be the most effective means of producing many commodities; public provision may be appropriate where universal access cannot be secured through ordinary exchange; cooperatives may enable producers and consumers to exercise collective control without surrendering individual initiative.
- Their economic justification does not extend to unrestricted monopolisation, the appropriation of public resources or the artificial restriction of opportunities available to others.
- Enterprise is not incompatible with shared responsibility; it can provide the resources through which that responsibility is fulfilled.
A civilisation is ultimately judged not by the magnificence of its buildings, the fortunes of its wealthiest citizens or the sophistication of its technology, but by the conditions under which its people live. The capacity to produce abundance alongside persistent deprivation poses a question that cannot be answered by statistics of aggregate growth alone. What is the purpose of economic organisation if the resources, knowledge and labour available to society cannot secure the necessities of a dignified existence for its members?
The Part I of this series distinguished physical scarcity from deprivation arising through exclusion. Twenty-two subsequent instalments examined wealth, labour, money, trade, debt, accumulation, institutions, technology and the distribution of productive opportunities. The penultimate part subjected the proposed relationships between distribution and production to the discipline of empirical inquiry. The task now is to articulate the organising principles of an economic civilisation capable of translating these insights into practice.
The economics of universal sustenance begins with a recognition of human interdependence. No individual creates the entire conditions of his or her prosperity. Even the most accomplished entrepreneur depends upon accumulated knowledge, infrastructure, workers, suppliers, customers and institutions that make exchange possible. Individual achievement is real and deserves recognition, but it takes place within a social inheritance that no individual produced alone. The maintenance and enlargement of that inheritance is a shared human responsibility.
Expenditure necessary to sustain human life should cease to be regarded as an optional act of generosity. Its justification need not rest upon moral exhortation, religious affiliation or the benevolence of those possessing surplus resources. It is a practical responsibility inherent in the organisation of an interdependent society. A child cannot be expected to earn the nutrition necessary for the development of the capacity to earn. Nor should an incapacitated person be required to demonstrate commercial usefulness before receiving essential care. Human existence is not conditional upon market valuation.
This conception has affinities with the capabilities approach developed by Amartya Sen, which places substantive freedom at the centre of development.[1] Universal sustenance, as proposed here, adds an explicit institutional question: how can the responsibility for sustaining and developing human capabilities be organised without creating new concentrations of power or undermining the incentives and resources necessary for production?
The answer cannot be found in either market absolutism or state absolutism. The neoliberal presumption that market outcomes ordinarily provide sufficient grounds for determining access to necessities overlooks the distinction between purchasing power and human need.
At the opposite extreme, the centralisation of economic decisions and productive assets under an unaccountable state may replace private domination with administrative domination. Neither criticism applies indiscriminately to every market economy or every socialist tradition. Actual economic systems contain diverse arrangements whose merits must be examined independently of their ideological labels.
The prudent middle path is not a compromise involving some predetermined division of ownership between the state and private individuals. It is a principle for selecting institutions according to their demonstrated capacity to serve human purposes.
Competitive enterprise may be the most effective means of producing many commodities; public provision may be appropriate where universal access cannot be secured through ordinary exchange; cooperatives may enable producers and consumers to exercise collective control without surrendering individual initiative. Elinor Ostrom’s research on collective governance demonstrates why the choice need not be confined to privatisation or centralised administration.[2]
Private ownership, legitimate profit and savings can facilitate innovation and productive investment. Their economic justification does not extend to unrestricted monopolisation, the appropriation of public resources or the artificial restriction of opportunities available to others. Similarly, public ownership does not establish that an enterprise serves the public. Both private and public institutions must be judged by their performance, the distribution of their benefits and the accountability of those exercising control.
Universal sustenance requires a dependable foundation of nutrition, safe water, sanitation, healthcare, education, shelter and protection against catastrophic economic losses. The precise standards and delivery arrangements must reflect available resources, local conditions and changing knowledge. Universal access does not mean unlimited consumption at public expense. It means that inability to pay should not exclude a person from an explicitly defined minimum necessary for a dignified existence. Above that foundation, diversity of preferences, enterprise, achievement and consumption can flourish.
Financing such arrangements requires more than declarations of entitlement. Broad and predictable taxation, effective administration, the removal of unjustified privileges and transparent expenditure priorities are essential. Contributions should reflect economic capacity without penalising productive activity through arbitrary or confiscatory demands. Public borrowing must be assessed against future obligations and the productive assets it creates. Resources devoted to ineffective programmes are resources denied to other human needs. The duty of accountability is as fundamental as the responsibility to contribute.
Pakistan illustrates the distance between these principles and institutional practice. Article 38 of the Constitution already envisages broad-based welfare, the reduction of disparities and provision of basic necessities to those unable to earn a livelihood.[3] Its fulfilment requires more than periodic relief packages. A credible transition would begin with identifying unmet needs, costing essential services, reviewing existing subsidies and tax privileges, and assigning responsibilities to institutions with adequate resources and measurable obligations. Local participation under a functioning system of decentralisation would help expose the difference between services announced and services actually delivered.
The distribution of productive opportunities must accompany the provision of necessities. Access to skills, land where appropriate, finance, technology and competitive markets can enable people to become creators of wealth rather than permanent recipients of assistance.
Unpaid care and contributions outside formal employment must also be recognised. Shared responsibility does not entail compulsory labour or make the right to sustenance dependent upon employment. Its purpose is to enlarge the opportunity to contribute freely, not to impose a uniform conception of usefulness.
Nor can universal sustenance be secured through unlimited material expansion. The resources inherited by future generations must enter present decisions. A society that finances its welfare by exhausting aquifers, destroying fertile soil or accumulating unsustainable liabilities merely relocates deprivation across time. International cooperation must likewise enlarge the capabilities of participating societies rather than institutionalise dependence. The geographical accident of birth should not determine the worth of a human life.
The proposed framework remains a research undertaking, not a claim to have discovered an infallible economic system. Its normative objective must be distinguished from predictions about the consequences of particular policies. The hypotheses developed in the preceding part require testing against credible alternatives, including their fiscal costs, effects on incentives, distributional consequences and ecological limits. Unfavourable evidence must lead to revision. The multidimensional measures proposed earlier in this series offer a basis for judging progress without concealing failures behind aggregate growth.
The ultimate transformation is one of purpose. Wealth is not the enemy of humanity; deprivation amid wealth is the challenge. Enterprise is not incompatible with shared responsibility; it can provide the resources through which that responsibility is fulfilled. Freedom is not secured merely by removing state restrictions, nor by promising collective provision. It requires institutions that protect individuals from arbitrary power and enlarge their actual capacity to choose.
The greatest achievement of an economic civilisation would not be that every human being possesses an equal fortune. It would be that no human being is denied the conditions necessary to develop his or her potential because another controls access to the means of existence. The creation of wealth, its productive circulation and the preservation of the natural world would then become complementary elements of a common endeavour. Humanity would cease to be an instrument of the economy; the economy would become an instrument of humanity.
Notes
[1] Amartya Sen (1999). Development as Freedom. Oxford University Press.
[3] Constitution of the Islamic Republic of Pakistan, Article 38 (Principles of Policy).
[Concluded]
Dr. Ikramul Haq, Advocate Supreme Court, Adjunct Faculty at Lahore University of Management Sciences (LUMS), member Advisory Board and Visiting Senior Fellow of Pakistan Institute of Development Economics (PIDE), holds an LLD in tax laws. He was full-time journalist from 1979 to 1984 with Viewpoint and Dawn. He also served Civil Services of Pakistan from 1984 to 1996.
We welcome your contributions! Submit your blogs, opinion pieces, press releases, news story pitches, and news features to opinion@minutemirror.com.pk and minutemirrormail@gmail.com

