ICJ’s Myanmar Genocide ruling could strengthen South Africa’s case against Israel

Khusbakht Bilal
5 Min Read

Summary

  • The International Court of Justice’s (ICJ) landmark decision holding Myanmar responsible for genocide against the Rohingya Muslim minority could have significant implications for South Africa’s ongoing genocide case against Israel over its military operations in Gaza.
  • A Significant Legal Precedent Israeli legal scholar Yuval Shany said the judgment could provide South Africa with additional legal arguments in its proceedings against Israel.
  • Focus on Women and Children Marieke de Hoon, a professor of international criminal law at the University of Amsterdam, said the ICJ’s emphasis on the systematic scale of crimes committed in Myanmar could also become relevant to the Gaza proceedings.
AI Generated Summary

The International Court of Justice’s (ICJ) landmark decision holding Myanmar responsible for genocide against the Rohingya Muslim minority could have significant implications for South Africa’s ongoing genocide case against Israel over its military operations in Gaza. Legal experts believe the ruling has established an important precedent by recognising that genocidal intent can exist alongside a state’s stated military objectives.

Although the situations in Myanmar and Gaza involve different circumstances, both cases concern alleged violations of the 1948 Genocide Convention, which requires countries to prevent and punish genocide.

On Thursday, the ICJ ruled that Myanmar had violated several provisions of the convention through the military’s treatment of the Rohingya population. The decision was welcomed by South Africa, which initiated proceedings against Israel over its conduct in Gaza.

South African Foreign Minister Ronald Lamola described the judgment as an important development, saying it established for the first time that a state had committed genocide. He also highlighted its significance for South Africa’s case against Israel, which is not expected to reach the main hearing stage until 2029.

Both Myanmar and Israel have defended their military operations as responses to security threats and armed insurgencies. However, nine judges on the 15-member ICJ bench concluded that Myanmar’s actions, including approximately 10,000 killings, widespread sexual violence, destruction of homes and the forced displacement of more than 700,000 Rohingya in 2017, constituted genocide.

The court also found that Myanmar had failed to fulfil its responsibility to prevent genocide. It ordered the country to facilitate the return of Rohingya refugees and provide reparations, although the amount has not yet been determined.

A Significant Legal Precedent

Israeli legal scholar Yuval Shany said the judgment could provide South Africa with additional legal arguments in its proceedings against Israel. Although the court maintained that genocidal intent must be the only reasonable explanation for the alleged actions, it expanded the circumstances judges can examine when assessing such intent.

These factors include the scale, systematic nature and historical background of the alleged crimes. According to Shany, this approach could create additional opportunities for South Africa to support its allegations concerning Gaza.

Under the Genocide Convention, proving genocide requires demonstrating an intention to destroy, entirely or partially, a national, ethnic, racial or religious group.

The convention identifies five acts that can constitute genocide, including killing members of a protected group, causing serious physical or psychological harm, deliberately creating destructive living conditions, preventing births and forcibly transferring children to another group.

Lamola said South Africa would carefully examine the ruling and consider how its findings could support arguments concerning the killing of children, sexual violence, forced displacement and destruction of civilian infrastructure.

Focus on Women and Children

Marieke de Hoon, a professor of international criminal law at the University of Amsterdam, said the ICJ’s emphasis on the systematic scale of crimes committed in Myanmar could also become relevant to the Gaza proceedings.

South Africa has alleged that Israel’s military campaign has created conditions affecting Palestinian births and disproportionately harmed women and children. Its submission to the court also claimed that approximately 70 per cent of those killed were non-combatants. Israel rejects the accusations and maintains that its military operations comply with international law.

De Hoon said the judgment challenged arguments that military objectives automatically exclude the possibility of genocidal intent. She explained that certain acts, particularly violence against women and children, could not necessarily be justified by military considerations alone.

Meanwhile, the Hague Initiative for International Cooperation (Thinc), a think tank funded by pro-Israeli groups, criticised the judgment, arguing that its interpretation could have serious consequences for Western military operations against terrorist organisations.

Despite differing reactions, legal experts believe the ruling represents a major development in international law. Richard Horsey of the International Crisis Group noted that although the legal threshold for proving genocide remains exceptionally high, the Myanmar case demonstrates that it can be met.

We welcome your contributions! Submit your blogs, opinion pieces, press releases, news story pitches, and news features to opinion@minutemirror.com.pk and minutemirrormail@gmail.com
Share This Article
Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *