Rs 1.42 billion health assets left uninsured in Punjab, 604 laptops worth Rs 149 million diverted, Audit reveals

Nadeem Tanoli
By
Nadeem Tanoli
The writer is a journalist based in Islamabad who has been covering parliamentary affairs for the past 15 years. He also reports on health, education, environmental,...
7 Min Read

Summary

  • Islamabad: Serious financial irregularities, unauthorized payments, missing medical equipment and alleged exploitation of tuberculosis patients have been exposed in Punjab’s Global Fund supported health programmes, with federal auditors questioning the handling of assets worth Rs 1.42 billion and the diversion of 604 laptops valued at Rs 149.188 million.
  • Auditors also found Rs 6.244 million in outstanding funds and assets linked to the Pakistan Anti TB Association, including Rs 1.848 million in recoverable funds and equipment worth Rs 4.395 million.
  • Another serious concern involved the expiry of donor funded TB medicines worth Rs 37.699 million in Punjab.
AI Generated Summary

Islamabad: Serious financial irregularities, unauthorized payments, missing medical equipment and alleged exploitation of tuberculosis patients have been exposed in Punjab’s Global Fund supported health programmes, with federal auditors questioning the handling of assets worth Rs 1.42 billion and the diversion of 604 laptops valued at Rs 149.188 million.

The special audit also revealed that funds approved for upgrading a tuberculosis laboratory in Multan were spent on a laboratory in Lahore, while patients entitled to free treatment were charged consultation fees by a doctor already receiving financial incentives from the programme.

According to the Auditor General of Pakistan’s Special Audit Report on Global Fund grants covering 2015 to 2023, serious weaknesses were found in the Punjab TB Control Programme, Punjab AIDS Control Programme and private organizations implementing donor funded healthcare activities.

The audit, conducted during October and November 2025, found that assets worth Rs 1.417 billion had not been insured from the time they were received.

These included Rs 1.382 billion in assets under the Punjab TB Control Programme and Rs 34.648 million under the Punjab AIDS Control Programme. The assets included medical equipment, laboratory machinery, computers, vehicles and office equipment.

Management stated that some insurance coverage had been arranged in 2023. However, auditors maintained that prolonged failure to insure the assets violated Global Fund requirements.

Another major objection involved 604 laptops worth Rs 149.188 million, allocated to Punjab in 2023 for tuberculosis data reporting. The auditors found that the laptops were handed over to Punjab’s Project Management Unit instead of being distributed directly to TB facilities under the approved plan.

Management claimed that the transfer followed an approved arrangement for the DHIS2 reporting system. However auditors rejected the explanation and recommended an inquiry, retrieval of the laptops and verification of their delivery to intended facilities.

The audit also identified questionable spending of Rs 22.102 million approved for upgrading two advanced TB laboratories in Lahore and Multan.

According to the report, the Multan laboratory was not upgraded, while the entire allocation was utilized for the Lahore facility.

Auditors also identified procurement violations, including late submission of bid security, expansion of the contract without required approval, absence of mandatory records and additional payments amounting to approximately 40 percent of the original contract value.

Management maintained that the revised work had received provincial administrative approval. The Departmental Accounts Committee directed an inquiry.

A particularly troubling finding concerned unauthorized consultation fees charged to TB patients despite the programme’s promise of free services.

The Association for Social Development, working under Mercy Corps, had engaged six private hospitals and 189 general physicians. Under the programme, participating doctors could receive Rs 800 per registered TB patient, while patients were not supposed to pay consultation fees.

However, auditors found that a doctor at Dr Sikandar Hayat Medicare Hospital was charging patients while also receiving programme incentives. Management argued that initial consultations could involve fees before confirmation of TB.

Auditors rejected this explanation and recommended recovery of unauthorized charges and action to prevent further exploitation.

The audit also questioned Rs 14.970 million in salaries paid to 51 Global Fund employees transferred to Punjab’s Secretary Operations and Monitoring Unit during 2023 without prior donor approval.

The Global Fund demanded repayment of the amount. Management stated that the employees had returned to their original positions in April 2025, but recovery had not been completed.

Furthermore, six Global Fund vehicles were found deployed with other government offices or personnel instead of being used exclusively for TB control activities.

The committee directed their immediate retrieval. At Ganga Ram Hospital, Lahore, a GeneXpert tuberculosis testing machine worth Rs 2.425 million was reported missing.

The machine had been installed in 2017, but testing stopped in 2020. Management said an inquiry was initiated in 2023, yet the equipment remained untraced. Auditors also found Rs 6.244 million in outstanding funds and assets linked to the Pakistan Anti TB Association, including Rs 1.848 million in recoverable funds and equipment worth Rs 4.395 million.

Another serious concern involved the expiry of donor funded TB medicines worth Rs 37.699 million in Punjab. The programme had also received medicines worth Rs 28.748 million with remaining shelf lives below prescribed limits.

Management attributed the problems partly to short dated supplies received from federal authorities, while auditors called for stronger inventory controls.

At Multan, auditors identified 16,328 medicines received with less than one month remaining before expiry. Management stated these were quarantined and returned without being issued to patients.

At Attock, 931 tablets expired at a TB treatment facility. The report also highlighted serious diagnostic concerns. In 2023, 77,460 of 112,916 TB cases reported by private facilities in Punjab were diagnosed clinically rather than confirmed through laboratory testing.

Auditors warned that inadequate supporting records could increase the risk of incorrect diagnosis and unnecessary treatment. Management maintained that clinical diagnosis is permitted in appropriate cases, but auditors demanded stronger verification.

Meanwhile, HIV treatment centres in Multan and Sargodha reported significant numbers of patients who stopped attending treatment. In 2023, Multan recorded 727 such patients, while Sargodha recorded 298.

Auditors warned that treatment interruptions could increase health risks and disease transmission. Other findings included theft of nine air conditioning units from treatment facilities in Bahawalpur and Sargodha, incomplete electronic TB surveillance and frequent changes in provincial programme leadership.

The Departmental Accounts Committee, meeting on January 27, 2026, directed inquiries, recovery efforts, improved controls and action against officials found responsible.

The audit has called for accountability, recovery of recoverable amounts, protection of donor funded equipment and better services for patients across Punjab.

We welcome your contributions! Submit your blogs, opinion pieces, press releases, news story pitches, and news features to opinion@minutemirror.com.pk and minutemirrormail@gmail.com
Share This Article
The writer is a journalist based in Islamabad who has been covering parliamentary affairs for the past 15 years. He also reports on health, education, environmental, and human rights issues. He can be reached at nadeemumer6@gmail.com.
Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *