Summary
- Pakistan may soon hold a nationwide referendum to seek public opinion on the proposed creation of new provinces, with voting results expected to be counted separately in each of the country’s four existing provinces.
- Sources said a strong public mandate in favour of new provinces would carry significant political and moral weight.
- A major question is whether Parliament and provincial assemblies would be constitutionally or politically bound to act on the results if voters in a particular province overwhelmingly supported the creation of new provinces.
Pakistan may soon hold a nationwide referendum to seek public opinion on the proposed creation of new provinces, with voting results expected to be counted separately in each of the country’s four existing provinces.
Under an initial framework being discussed by relevant quarters, the referendum would identify which districts and cities support the establishment of new administrative units. The proposal aims to assess public demand before decisions are made about the number, boundaries and formation of additional provinces.
Sources familiar with the discussions said the debate over creating new provinces had been ongoing for the past three months. They argued that the issue should not remain unresolved indefinitely and that public opinion must be established through a clear process.
The proposed referendum would produce separate results for each province. Decisions would be based on majority opinion, allowing voters in each province to express their views on the proposed administrative restructuring.
Sources said a strong public mandate in favour of new provinces would carry significant political and moral weight. They added that elected representatives could find it difficult to disregard the people’s expressed wishes.
The proposed provinces would be established on administrative rather than linguistic or ethnic grounds. Each new province would have its own provincial assembly, chief minister and cabinet. The chief minister would remain the province’s chief executive, with no proposal to transfer executive powers to an empowered mayor or bureaucratic administrator.
Article 48(6) of the Constitution is being cited as the legal basis for holding a referendum on an issue of national importance. However, several constitutional and political questions surrounding the proposed exercise remain unresolved.
One key provision is Article 239(4), which requires a resolution supported by at least a two-thirds majority in the relevant provincial assembly for the creation of a new province. Sources acknowledged this requirement but argued that elected representatives would face considerable political pressure if voters clearly endorsed the proposal.
A major question is whether Parliament and provincial assemblies would be constitutionally or politically bound to act on the results if voters in a particular province overwhelmingly supported the creation of new provinces.
Sources said rejecting a clear public mandate could trigger serious constitutional and political questions. Any dispute arising from a situation in which voters supported the proposal but elected representatives opposed it would require legal interpretation.
Punjab Assembly Speaker Malik Ahmad Khan has previously said that the Federal Constitutional Court was established to decide constitutional questions of this nature if they arise.
The proposed framework does not specify how many provinces Pakistan could eventually have. Sources described speculation about the creation of 12 or 14 provinces as premature, saying the first step was to determine public preferences. The referendum would help establish which areas favour separate administrative provinces and could guide future decisions on their number and boundaries.
The federal government’s position on the proposal has also drawn attention. Sources claimed the government supported the initiative and said statements by the defence and information ministers reflected its position.
They dismissed concerns that the proposed referendum could intensify political tensions or lead to confrontation. They also rejected suggestions that the restructuring could weaken political parties or form part of a move towards a presidential system.
On the possibility of placing Karachi and Gwadar under federal administration, sources said the immediate priority was to hold the referendum and determine public opinion. They added that if people wanted the two cities to become part of federal territory in the future, the option could be considered.
The Election Commission of Pakistan is expected to supervise the proposed referendum. Sources also dismissed concerns that the security situation in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and Balochistan would prevent the exercise from taking place.
They described warnings of possible bloodshed in Sindh over the creation of new provinces as speculation, arguing that there were no indications of an uncontrollable situation.
Neither the number of proposed provinces nor their geographical boundaries have been finalised. However, the initiative appears to have opened a new political debate, particularly over the position of the Pakistan Peoples Party, a key partner in the current ruling arrangement.
The party could emerge as a potential obstacle to the proposal, raising questions about whether the federal government will be able to convince its important ally or whether disagreements over the issue will put further pressure on the ruling coalition.
We welcome your contributions! Submit your blogs, opinion pieces, press releases, news story pitches, and news features to opinion@minutemirror.com.pk and minutemirrormail@gmail.com

