Foreign court decrees not directly enforceable in Pakistan: SC

Hadia Batool
By
Hadia Batool
Hadia Batool is Web Editor of Minute Mirror. She can be reached at bhadia624@gmail.com.
3 Min Read

Summary

  • ISLAMABAD: The Supreme Court of Pakistan has ruled that a foreign court decree cannot be directly enforced in the country, delivering an important judgment on the legal requirements for recognising and executing judgments issued by overseas courts.
  • Without such a legal provision, a local appellate court could not be considered equivalent to a federal court for the purpose of enforcing its judgments in Pakistan.
  • The Supreme Court’s ruling establishes important legal principles concerning the enforcement of foreign court judgments, the distinction between federal and local judicial authorities in the UAE, and the interpretation of Section 44-A of the Code of Civil Procedure.
AI Generated Summary

ISLAMABAD: The Supreme Court of Pakistan has ruled that a foreign court decree cannot be directly enforced in the country, delivering an important judgment on the legal requirements for recognising and executing judgments issued by overseas courts.

The apex court accepted an appeal filed by a private company by a 2-1 majority and set aside the orders issued by the Lahore High Court and the subordinate court.

The case examined the legal status of federal courts in the United Arab Emirates (UAE), particularly the federal and local courts of Abu Dhabi, and whether their judgments could be enforced in Pakistan under the country’s existing legal framework.

In the majority judgment, Justice Munib Akhtar and Justice Muhammad Shafi Siddiqui held that the Abu Dhabi Court of Appeal could not be treated as a federal appellate court of the UAE.

The judges observed that transferring the judicial powers of local courts to federal courts required specific federal legislation. Without such a legal provision, a local appellate court could not be considered equivalent to a federal court for the purpose of enforcing its judgments in Pakistan.

The Supreme Court further ruled that the Lahore High Court lacked the authority to enforce the disputed foreign decree in Pakistan under Section 44-A of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC).

Consequently, the apex court concluded that the orders passed by the subordinate court and the Lahore High Court could not be sustained and set them aside.

The case had initially resulted in a difference of opinion among members of the two-judge bench, following which the matter was referred to a third judge to resolve the disagreement.

Justice Muhammad Shafi Siddiqui, acting as the referee judge, agreed with the position taken by Justice Munib Akhtar. His agreement resulted in a majority decision in favour of the private company’s appeal.

However, Justice Irfan Saadat Khan disagreed with the majority ruling and issued a dissenting opinion.

In his dissent, Justice Saadat Khan maintained that the original court’s decree had merged into the decision of the appellate court. Therefore, the decree under consideration should be treated as one issued by the appellate court.

He further argued that the UAE was a reciprocating territory recognised by Pakistan for the enforcement of foreign judgments. On this basis, he held that the appellate court’s decree could be enforced in Pakistan.

The Supreme Court’s ruling establishes important legal principles concerning the enforcement of foreign court judgments, the distinction between federal and local judicial authorities in the UAE, and the interpretation of Section 44-A of the Code of Civil Procedure.

The decision also clarifies the legal requirements that foreign judicial decrees must satisfy before they can be enforced through Pakistani courts.

We welcome your contributions! Submit your blogs, opinion pieces, press releases, news story pitches, and news features to opinion@minutemirror.com.pk and minutemirrormail@gmail.com
Share This Article
Hadia Batool is Web Editor of Minute Mirror. She can be reached at bhadia624@gmail.com.
Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *