Summary
- The 2025 Human Development Report also retains an index adjusted for planetary pressures.[2] These instruments illuminate aspects of development that national income alone cannot reveal, although none captures the entirety of human freedom.
- A framework for evaluating shared prosperity could begin with five interconnected dimensions: productive performance, distribution of income and assets, human capabilities, economic security and ecological sustainability.
- Real output per worker and investment illuminate productive capacity; median disposable income, poverty and wealth shares reveal distribution; learning outcomes and healthy life expectancy reflect capabilities; exposure to catastrophic expenses and insecure employment indicate vulnerability; and physical resource accounts help assess sustainability.
What should a nation measure to determine whether its people are becoming more prosperous? The preceding instalment argued that international economic exchanges should be judged by their contribution to human capabilities rather than by their volume alone. The same principle applies within national borders. An economy may expand without improving the lives of a substantial proportion of its inhabitants. The difficulty is not necessarily that its statistics are wrong, but that the questions those statistics answer are different from the questions society needs to ask.
Gross domestic product (GDP) measures the value of final production within an economy during a specified period. It remains indispensable for analysing economic activity, business cycles, fiscal capacity and structural transformation. The error arises when a measure of production is treated as a comprehensive measure of prosperity. GDP does not reveal who receives the income generated, how secure their livelihoods are or whether the assets supporting future production are being depleted.
The commission chaired by Joseph Stiglitz, with Amartya Sen as adviser and Jean-Paul Fitoussi as coordinator, addressed these distinctions in its 2009 report on economic performance and social progress. Subsequent OECD research developed the case for a broader set of indicators covering material living standards, inequality, quality of life and sustainability.[1] The objective was not to abandon national accounts but to prevent their use for purposes they were never designed to fulfil.
Consider two hypothetical economies, each with ten inhabitants and an annual income of 100 units. In the first, every inhabitant receives ten units. In the second, one receives 55 and the remaining nine receive five each. Average income is identical, but median income and the distribution of purchasing power differ substantially. If eight units are required to meet basic needs, the first economy has no income deprivation under that threshold, while nine inhabitants of the second fall below it. This illustration establishes no universal relationship between inequality and growth. It demonstrates why an average cannot describe the distribution of the resources it summarises.
Even household income is an incomplete measure. Two families receiving identical incomes may face different housing costs, medical expenses, disabilities or access to public services. A household with reliable public healthcare and education may enjoy greater effective security than one compelled to purchase both privately. Measurement must therefore distinguish monetary resources from the actual opportunities those resources make possible.
The United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) has sought to broaden the assessment of progress through the Human Development Index (HDI), which combines indicators of health, education and income. Its inequality-adjusted index accounts for disparities in those dimensions, while its multidimensional poverty index identifies overlapping deprivations. The 2025 Human Development Report also retains an index adjusted for planetary pressures.[2]
These instruments illuminate aspects of development that national income alone cannot reveal, although none captures the entirety of human freedom. An equally important omission concerns unpaid work. A person caring for children, elderly relatives or a family member with a disability contributes to the maintenance of human capabilities even when no payment is received. If the same service is purchased from a professional provider, it ordinarily enters measured production.
The difference in accounting treatment does not establish a corresponding difference in social usefulness. Research published by the International Labour Organization (ILO) in 2018, drawing on time-use data from 64 countries, estimated that unpaid care work occupied 16.4 billion hours daily worldwide, with women performing more than three-quarters of those hours.[3]
Time-use surveys can reveal whether technological progress actually reduces the burdens of work or merely transfers them between paid employment and households. Supplementary accounts can estimate the value of unpaid services, but their results depend upon the valuation method. The objective is not to assign a market price to every human relationship. It is to recognise activities essential to economic life that conventional production accounts largely exclude.
A further distinction, developed in Part XIX, concerns income and wealth. Income is a flow; wealth is a stock of assets capable of supporting future benefits. Extracting minerals may increase current GDP while reducing natural wealth.
Rebuilding infrastructure after a disaster generates measured production, but the destruction of existing assets is not thereby transformed into prosperity. The World Bank’s Changing Wealth of Nations 2024 reports that global real wealth per capita increased by 21 per cent between 1995 and 2020, while 27 countries experienced declines or little change.[4] Aggregate progress can conceal divergent national experiences, just as national averages can conceal household deprivation.
Comprehensive wealth accounting incorporates produced capital, natural capital, human capital and net foreign assets. Monetary estimates are useful, but they cannot establish that every ecological loss can be compensated by additional machinery or financial assets. Physical indicators of groundwater, soil quality, biodiversity and emissions remain necessary, especially where damage may be irreversible. Pakistan illustrates the practical importance of these distinctions. An assessment of development should connect national accounts with household income and expenditure surveys, labour-force statistics, educational outcomes, health indicators and regional measures of deprivation.
A rise in tax collections, for instance, tells little about the distribution of the burden or the quality of services financed. An increase in agricultural output does not establish whether tenants, landless workers and small farmers have acquired greater security. The expansion of credit does not reveal whether financing reaches productive enterprises or remains concentrated among established borrowers.
A framework for evaluating shared prosperity could begin with five interconnected dimensions: productive performance, distribution of income and assets, human capabilities, economic security and ecological sustainability. Each requires separate indicators. Real output per worker and investment illuminate productive capacity; median disposable income, poverty and wealth shares reveal distribution; learning outcomes and healthy life expectancy reflect capabilities; exposure to catastrophic expenses and insecure employment indicate vulnerability; and physical resource accounts help assess sustainability. Time available for rest, care and participation deserves attention alongside these measures.
No single composite index should conceal conflicts between these objectives. A rise in average income cannot automatically compensate for a deterioration in drinking water or an increase in severe deprivation. Assigning weights to different dimensions involves value judgements that should be made explicit. Statistical uncertainty, missing observations and changes in definitions must also be disclosed. A dashboard of indicators, disaggregated by region, gender and income group wherever data permit, would allow competing interpretations to be examined rather than suppressed by a single headline figure.
Such a framework also makes the central hypothesis of this series amenable to investigation. If broader access to productive resources and essential services strengthens future productive capacity, improvements in distribution and capabilities should, under identifiable conditions, precede improvements in productivity and economic resilience. Establishing causation would require more than observing simultaneous changes. It would require longitudinal evidence, credible comparisons and attention to alternative explanations, including institutional quality, demographic change and external shocks.
The purpose of measurement is ultimately to distinguish an attractive proposition from a defensible economic explanation. A society may produce more without becoming more secure, accumulate assets without expanding freedom, or increase present consumption at the expense of its descendants. Its success must be assessed through the relationship between what it produces, how the benefits are distributed, what people are actually able to do and what remains available to future generations.
The next part will bring these dimensions together in a theoretical framework for the economics of shared prosperity.
Notes
- UNDP, Human Development Report 2025, Readers’ Guide and technical notes.
- International Labour Organization, Care Work and Care Jobs for the Future of Decent Work, 2018, chapter 2.
- World Bank, The Changing Wealth of Nations 2024.
[To be continued]
______________________________________________________________________
Dr. Ikramul Haq, Advocate Supreme Court, Adjunct Faculty at Lahore University of Management Sciences (LUMS), member Advisory Board and Visiting Senior Fellow of Pakistan Institute of Development Economics (PIDE), holds an LLD in tax laws. He was full-time journalist from 1979 to 1984 with Viewpoint and Dawn. He also served Civil Services of Pakistan from 1984 to 1996.
We welcome your contributions! Submit your blogs, opinion pieces, press releases, news story pitches, and news features to opinion@minutemirror.com.pk and minutemirrormail@gmail.com

