Summary
- The Lahore High Court (LHC) has ruled that a privately arranged DNA test cannot override the legal presumption that a child born during a valid marriage is legitimate, dismissing a father’s petition challenging maintenance awarded to his minor son and the recovery of dowry articles.
- The court referred to Article 128 of the Qanun-e-Shahadat Order, 1984, which establishes a conclusive presumption of a child’s legitimacy when the child is born during a valid marriage, subject to legally recognised exceptions.
- The court also noted that the father had arranged the DNA test secretly, without judicial permission or the mother’s consent, raising concerns about privacy, personal liberty and dignity.
The Lahore High Court (LHC) has ruled that a privately arranged DNA test cannot override the legal presumption that a child born during a valid marriage is legitimate, dismissing a father’s petition challenging maintenance awarded to his minor son and the recovery of dowry articles.
Justice Asad Ali Bajwa dismissed a petition filed by Usama Tahir and others against Zainab Irfan and others, observing that a father cannot deny a child’s parentage solely on the basis of a privately obtained DNA report.
The court stressed that paternity disputes require careful consideration, particularly when they involve minors, whose dignity, privacy and emotional well-being must remain protected. It added that DNA testing should not become a routine exercise and must serve the child’s best interests.
According to the judgment, the parties married on August 18, 2019, and their son was born on April 27, 2022, while the marriage remained intact.
The court referred to Article 128 of the Qanun-e-Shahadat Order, 1984, which establishes a conclusive presumption of a child’s legitimacy when the child is born during a valid marriage, subject to legally recognised exceptions. It also noted that members of the father’s family admitted during court proceedings that the marriage remained intact when the child was born.
The father had challenged the child’s paternity by presenting a DNA report allegedly obtained from a private laboratory in the United Kingdom. The report reportedly excluded him as the child’s biological father.
However, the court found no evidence that a competent court had ordered or supervised the test. It ruled that a privately commissioned report could not, on its own, defeat the legal presumption of legitimacy.
The judgment further highlighted that courts must protect children’s fundamental rights and prevent unnecessary emotional harm. It said DNA testing in paternity disputes requires judicial scrutiny and cannot be ordered simply because one party demands it or scientific facilities are available. Even parental consent does not remove the court’s responsibility to assess whether testing serves the child’s best interests.
The court also noted that the father had arranged the DNA test secretly, without judicial permission or the mother’s consent, raising concerns about privacy, personal liberty and dignity.
Referring to Articles 4, 9 and 14 of the Constitution, the LHC maintained that the law protects every person’s liberty, privacy and dignity from unlawful interference.
The judgment also cited the Muslim Personal Law (Shariat) Application Act, 1962, and the Supreme Court’s ruling in *Ghazala Tehsin Zohra v. Mehr Ghulam Dastgir Khan*. It observed that the legal principle discussed in the Supreme Court judgment requires a Muslim father challenging a child’s paternity to do so within a maximum period of 40 days after the child’s birth.
We welcome your contributions! Submit your blogs, opinion pieces, press releases, news story pitches, and news features to opinion@minutemirror.com.pk and minutemirrormail@gmail.com

