Summary
- Federal Health Minister Mustafa Kamal on Wednesday warned Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP) Chairman Bilawal Bhutto-Zardari that he would be held responsible for any bloodshed linked to the demand for creating new provinces in Sindh.
- Isran maintained that creating new provinces, encouraging ethnic divisions and using political pressure were not solutions to the problems of urban Sindh.
- The exchange has intensified the political debate over the creation of new provinces, the performance of the Sindh government and the distribution of administrative and economic resources in the province.
Federal Health Minister Mustafa Kamal on Wednesday warned Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP) Chairman Bilawal Bhutto-Zardari that he would be held responsible for any bloodshed linked to the demand for creating new provinces in Sindh.
Speaking at a press conference at the National Press Club in Islamabad, Kamal criticised Bilawal’s remarks about the possibility of violence in Karachi, Hyderabad, Mirpurkhas and Sukkur over the proposed division of Sindh.
He said any loss of life resulting from the controversy would be Bilawal’s responsibility, stressing that the creation of smaller provinces was necessary to improve governance and protect the country’s future.
Kamal questioned the PPP’s opposition to new provinces, asking why the party feared administrative division if it believed its 18-year rule in Sindh had delivered good governance. He said there should be no objection to dividing Sindh into even 10 provinces, each with its own chief minister.
The minister maintained that the Constitution provided a legal mechanism for creating new provinces and could be amended when necessary. He pointed out that the 1973 Constitution had already undergone 27 amendments.
Criticising the PPP’s performance in Sindh, Kamal alleged that urban residents had been denied their fair share of government employment. He claimed that the 40 per cent urban quota was not being implemented and that fake domicile certificates were being used to deprive eligible candidates of jobs.
He further claimed that Sindh had received around Rs22 trillion since the introduction of the 18th Constitutional Amendment, but essential public services remained inadequate.
Highlighting governance problems, he referred to incidents involving children falling into open drains, shortages of drinking water and inadequate medicines in hospitals. He also said employment opportunities for young people in Karachi had become increasingly limited.
Kamal accused the provincial government of neglecting urban communities and alleged that the Muhajir community had faced discrimination and violence over the years. Referring to unrest following former prime minister Benazir Bhutto’s assassination, he claimed that Muhajir-owned businesses had been targeted in different parts of Sindh.
Defending his performance as Karachi mayor, Kamal said development projects worth Rs300 billion had been completed during his tenure. He claimed that Karachi had ranked among the world’s 12 fastest-growing cities during that period.
He also cited water supply projects in Lyari and the islands of Baba, Bhit and Shams Pir, as well as Salehabad, saying around 60,000 families had benefited. He particularly mentioned an underwater pipeline project designed to provide water to island communities.
The minister challenged the PPP to produce evidence that he had illegally acquired even a single yard of land during his time as mayor. He also denied involvement in illegal businesses involving marriage halls, petrol pumps, water hydrants or tanker operations since leaving office in 2010.
The Sindh government strongly rejected Kamal’s statements, accusing him of promoting political division and making unfounded allegations against the provincial administration.
Responding to the minister, Sindh government spokesperson Ghanwer Khan Isran questioned his political standing and criticised what he described as his confrontational approach. He said Kamal lacked the public support to win even a councillor’s seat and accused him of displaying arrogance over a federal ministry.
Isran alleged that MQM ministers were attempting to weaken the federal government and create political instability. He also accused Kamal of pursuing political conspiracies while remaining part of the federal cabinet.
Responding to questions raised about provincial assemblies and their constitutional authority, Isran challenged the minister to explain the constitutional basis of his own federal ministry if he questioned the legitimacy of provincial institutions.
He said casting doubt on provincial assemblies amounted to disrespecting the mandate of people across the country. He added that the Constitution could not be interpreted according to the political interests of individual leaders.
The spokesperson also dismissed Kamal’s claim that Sindh had received Rs22 trillion, describing the figure as political propaganda. He demanded that the minister provide authentic financial documents and expenditure records to support his allegations.
Isran maintained that creating new provinces, encouraging ethnic divisions and using political pressure were not solutions to the problems of urban Sindh. He urged the MQM leadership to avoid statements that could threaten the province’s peace and social cohesion.
He further challenged Kamal to resign from the federal cabinet if he disagreed with the prime minister, questioning why the minister continued to hold office while allegedly working against the government’s interests.
The exchange has intensified the political debate over the creation of new provinces, the performance of the Sindh government and the distribution of administrative and economic resources in the province.
We welcome your contributions! Submit your blogs, opinion pieces, press releases, news story pitches, and news features to opinion@minutemirror.com.pk and minutemirrormail@gmail.com

