New Provinces, Old Questions

Ahmad Hassan
8 Min Read

Summary

  • Over time, though, the state machinery grew bigger than the political society meant to steer it.
  • A useful picture comes from Daron Acemoglu and James Robinson, who argue in their book The Narrow Corridor that liberty survives only in a narrow corridor, where a state strong enough to protect meets a society organised enough to hold it to account.
  • We might solve a few problems by creating new and smaller provinces, but it is time to look at the deeper questions: who this state is for, what it owes, and who holds it to account.
AI Generated Summary

Pakistan stands at a crossroads, as it has many times before. This time the conversation has turned to governance, devolution and new provinces.

A few months back, Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi said the present system has collapsed. He called for new administrative units or provinces. A day after these remarks, the military spokesperson was asked whether Pakistan is a hard state. His answer was ‘Unfortunately not.’ He explained that we need a hard state for governance problems. According to him, the term means one law for all. In March 2025, the Field Marshal and Chief of Defence Forces urged Pakistan to become a ‘hard state.’ In simple terms, the solutions suggested by the state are a hard state and smaller administrative units.

The discussion on ‘new provinces’ is significant. It is quite reasonable to argue that smaller units would bring government closer to the people and make services easier to deliver. That case deserves a hearing. But a question must come first: is it the only, or the most important, thing we need right now? Questions like these should also be asked. Now is the time to broaden the horizon of discussion. We should see this as an opportunity to meaningfully discuss our political system, because once a topic enters public discussion, it needs to be viewed from all angles. So, let us ask some questions.

Start with the state: where it came from, and who it was built for. We inherited colonial rule, and with it a police force, a bureaucracy and an army built to control a population. They served that purpose well. Over time, though, the state machinery grew bigger than the political society meant to steer it. Any discussion today must include the how and why of that imbalance, and of the long struggle for genuine local government.

Unfortunately, power did not merely centralise. It pooled in institutions that answer to each other and rarely to the citizen. The deepest reason is that a stable, mature pathway for a citizen’s government has never been able to take root. Political parties rarely practised democracy within their own ranks, and provincial leaders consistently starved local governments of power and funds. This particular issue of political pathway is at the root of many of our problems. Redraw the provinces on these foundations and we will face the same issues.

Now, it is equally important to look at our society. The distance between the state and the citizen has been growing for decades, and it shows up in our society. Our distrust has crept down to the most basic level. Many people think of this as a state of the elite, for the elite and by the elite. Worse, that has become normal. If it were happening to a few people, we could call it an exception. It is felt by nearly everyone.

So, access to the state and trust in it are both compromised. Citizens doubt their courts. The public does not feel powerful enough to call itself part of the political system because many feel their ballot no longer decides who governs them. And, as a result, many believe, and rightly so, that the future has no certain direction as far as our political life is concerned.

Part of this disconnect stems from an overriding security-state mindset. Recognising this does not mean that the approach should be set aside completely. We have lost too many lives to terrorism for anyone to wave it away. It matters, and the state has a duty to protect.

But how that duty is performed has to be questioned, as does how, sometimes, it becomes a tool or reason for harsher steps. We have followed a pattern for a long time now. We seek extraordinary solutions for every problem. First there are extraordinary measures for terrorism, then for politics, and now for crime. Each one is announced as temporary. Each one lowers the bar for the next.

Here the important question is whether order must come before liberty in unstable societies.

Let us assume, for a moment, that the hard state is the solution. Most states in history have claimed a purpose, even the harder ones: prosperity, equality, territory, a cause. What exactly is ours? The spokesperson’s answer was a state where the law applies equally to everyone. It is a fine purpose. Critics of the term fear something harsher: a state that rules by force rather than by consent. So let us look at our recent efforts at enforcing the law and see which of the two we are building.

Take Punjab’s Crime Control Department (CCD) as an example. The government views it as a solution to high crime rates. Police figures claim a 64% fall in property crime and a 60% fall in robbery-murder. The recent Human Rights Commission of Pakistan report raises serious concerns about allegations of a deliberate policy of staged encounters leading to extrajudicial killings. If those allegations are borne out, the policy reflects a loss of the right to a dignified life. People tend to obey laws they find fair, not laws they find frightening. Fear does not buy trust.

Nor can that trust rest on courts that people believe no longer stand apart from power. At the federal level, the 26th and 27th Amendments reshaped our judicial system. Critics, including the International Commission of Jurists on the 26th Amendment, say these changes weaken the courts’ freedom from the executive. Without an independent judiciary, a modern welfare state cannot be imagined, whether it has a smaller or a larger number of provinces.

These factors indicate that our state and society are both failing badly. This time we should not run away from reality, and all factions of our society must raise their voices.

A useful picture comes from Daron Acemoglu and James Robinson, who argue in their book The Narrow Corridor that liberty survives only in a narrow corridor, where a state strong enough to protect meets a society organised enough to hold it to account. We have a state that looks strong and a society that is distrustful and disconnected, and we are nowhere near that corridor.

That is the crossroads we stand at. We might solve a few problems by creating new and smaller provinces, but it is time to look at the deeper questions: who this state is for, what it owes, and who holds it to account. Left unanswered for decades, these questions of life, liberty and politics have shaped our troubles, and they will go on doing so unless we act.

We welcome your contributions! Submit your blogs, opinion pieces, press releases, news story pitches, and news features to opinion@minutemirror.com.pk and minutemirrormail@gmail.com
Share This Article
Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *