Rs 106 billion refund controversy deepens as FBR sanctions Rs 37 billion, releases only Rs 28 billion

Nadeem Tanoli
By
Nadeem Tanoli
The writer is a journalist based in Islamabad who has been covering parliamentary affairs for the past 15 years. He also reports on health, education, environmental,...
6 Min Read

Summary

  • Islamabad:  The Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) has come under serious scrutiny in the Senate over delays in settling billions of rupees in petroleum sector sales tax refunds, with officials admitting that Rs 66 billion in claims remain deferred because of documentation discrepancies, while petroleum companies maintain that approximately Rs 72 billion has remained unadjusted since 2022 to 2024.
  • The controversy intensified after FBR disclosed that against total refund claims of Rs 106 billion, only Rs 28 billion had been disbursed to petroleum companies, raising concerns about financial pressure on the industry and the handling of legitimate tax refunds.
  • Representatives of the Oil Companies Advisory Council (OCAC) informed the committee that approximately Rs 72 billion in input sales tax claims had accumulated during the zero rated and exempt tax arrangements between 2022 and 2024.
AI Generated Summary

Islamabad:  The Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) has come under serious scrutiny in the Senate over delays in settling billions of rupees in petroleum sector sales tax refunds, with officials admitting that Rs 66 billion in claims remain deferred because of documentation discrepancies, while petroleum companies maintain that approximately Rs 72 billion has remained unadjusted since 2022 to 2024.

The controversy intensified after FBR disclosed that against total refund claims of Rs 106 billion, only Rs 28 billion had been disbursed to petroleum companies, raising concerns about financial pressure on the industry and the handling of legitimate tax refunds.

The matter was discussed during a meeting of the Senate Standing Committee on Cabinet Secretariat, chaired by Senator Rana Mahmood ul Hassan at Parliament House, Islamabad.

Representatives of the Oil Companies Advisory Council (OCAC) informed the committee that approximately Rs 72 billion in input sales tax claims had accumulated during the zero rated and exempt tax arrangements between 2022 and 2024.

They complained that the prolonged nonpayment of refunds was placing a heavy financial burden on petroleum companies, which were paying substantial bank markup charges while waiting for their claims to be settled.

The industry representatives stressed that delays in releasing legitimate refunds were affecting companies’ financial position and operational activities.

Responding to the concerns, FBR officials presented their own figures regarding the outstanding claims.

According to the tax authorities, total refund claims stood at Rs 106 billion, of which Rs 37 billion had been sanctioned.

Officials informed the committee that Rs 28 billion had already been disbursed, while Rs 7 billion was under process.

They further disclosed that Rs 66 billion in claims had been deferred because of mismatches in supporting documents.

The chairman expressed concern over the unresolved claims and directed FBR and representatives of the oil industry to undertake a joint reconciliation exercise within the next month.

The committee instructed the concerned parties to verify the documents, identify genuine claims and take steps to clear valid refunds.

Importantly, the chairman directed that the reconciliation process should proceed without issuing punitive show cause notices to petroleum companies.

Another important issue concerning FBR emerged when the committee discussed the department’s recent internal proficiency assessment.

Chairman Senator Rana Mahmood ul Hassan referred to media reports suggesting that only a small number of FBR officers had passed the assessment.

He observed that the reported results pointed towards technical capacity gaps within the country’s main tax collection institution.

However, the chairman appreciated the FBR leadership for conducting an internal assessment and making its findings public, describing the initiative as a positive step towards institutional improvement.

The discussion nevertheless raised questions about the need for better technical training and professional development within FBR.

The committee also examined delays in introducing promotion rules for departmental officers.

The Establishment Division informed the senators that FBR had not yet formulated the required rules or approached the Federal Public Service Commission (FPSC) regarding the examination for the 20 percent promotion quota, including posts such as Assistant Collector.

Officials explained that the Establishment Division and FPSC could proceed with finalizing the rules only after FBR submitted the required requisition.

They further informed the committee that approval from the Prime Minister would be obtained wherever required.

The disclosure raised questions about the delay in providing a formal examination mechanism for eligible departmental officers seeking promotion.

The committee also discussed the impact of illegal petroleum trade and counterfeit lubricants on government revenue.

During the meeting, concerns were raised that fuel smuggling and adulteration were causing estimated losses of Rs 1 billion to Rs 1.5 billion daily to the national exchequer.

Industry representatives claimed that counterfeit lubricants accounted for nearly 35 percent of Pakistan’s lubricant market, representing approximately 150 million litres out of a total market of 450 million litres.

They warned that the illegal trade resulted in substantial tax evasion while also damaging vehicle engines and contributing to environmental pollution.

These were estimates and claims presented during the committee proceedings rather than independently verified findings of FBR revenue losses.

The chairman announced that another joint meeting would be convened the following week involving the Ministries of Finance and Petroleum, FBR, the Oil and Gas Regulatory Authority and the relevant Senate committees.

The proposed meeting will focus on resolving outstanding refund claims, petroleum margin and exchange rate issues, and other pending regulatory matters.

We welcome your contributions! Submit your blogs, opinion pieces, press releases, news story pitches, and news features to opinion@minutemirror.com.pk and minutemirrormail@gmail.com
Share This Article
The writer is a journalist based in Islamabad who has been covering parliamentary affairs for the past 15 years. He also reports on health, education, environmental, and human rights issues. He can be reached at nadeemumer6@gmail.com.
Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *