Summary
- Under Article 239(4), a constitutional amendment that alters the limits of a province cannot be presented to the President for assent unless it has first been passed by that provincial assembly by a two-thirds majority of its total membership.
- This is why constitutional experts are drawing a clear line: Article 48(6) allows a matter of national importance to be put to a referendum after approval by a joint sitting of Parliament, although a referendum itself would not create a new province.
- A nationwide referendum could show majority support for new provinces in general, but it cannot override the specific constitutional protection given to the province being divided.
For years, the demand for new provinces in Pakistan has returned in every election season South Punjab, Hazara, Bahawalpur, Karachi, and now talk of 10 to 12 provinces across the country.
This time, a new constitutional phrase has entered the debate: Article 48(6).
Supporters present it as a democratic breakthrough. Critics call it a detour. Both are partly right, because Article 48(6) does something important, but it does not do what many headlines suggest.
It does not create a province.
What Article 48(6) Actually Says:
Article 48 deals with the President and the advice of the Prime Minister. Its clause (6) says that where the Prime Minister considers it necessary to hold a referendum on any matter of national importance, he may refer the matter to a joint sitting of Parliament.
If the joint sitting approves, the matter can be put to the people in a referendum.
That is the provision now being discussed: the Prime Minister can seek Parliament’s permission for a referendum on an issue of national importance, and the creation of new provinces is being framed as such an issue.
In plain language: Article 48(6) allows the government to ask the people a question. It does not allow the government to skip Parliament.
Why a Referendum Alone Is Not Enough:
Pakistan’s Constitution has a separate, specific procedure for changing provincial boundaries.
Under Article 239(4), a constitutional amendment that alters the limits of a province cannot be presented to the President for assent unless it has first been passed by that provincial assembly by a two-thirds majority of its total membership.
And that is only the first lock. The amendment must also secure a two thirds majority in both the National Assembly and the Senate.
This is why constitutional experts are drawing a clear line: Article 48(6) allows a matter of national importance to be put to a referendum after approval by a joint sitting of Parliament, although a referendum itself would not create a new province.
A referendum can build moral and political pressure. It cannot amend Article 1 of the Constitution, which names the provinces. It cannot redraw a boundary. It cannot replace the consent of the affected province.
To confuse the two is to confuse a public opinion poll with a constitutional amendment.
Then Why Talk About a Referendum at All?
If Article 48(6) cannot create a province, why is the government reportedly completing preparations for it?
Because politics matters as much as law.
Creating new provinces ordinarily requires a two-thirds constitutional majority in both houses of Parliament, together with the consent of the assembly whose territory is being divided. That is a very high bar deliberately so. The framers of the Constitution did not want provinces to be broken up by a simple majority in Islamabad against the will of the people who live there.
A referendum changes the political calculation. If millions vote in favour of a new province, it becomes much harder for a provincial assembly or a national party to say no without paying a political price. It gives the demand democratic legitimacy. It forces parties that have supported new provinces in speeches to take a stand in a vote.
In that sense, Article 48(6) is useful , not as a legal shortcut, but as a democratic signal.
The Real Test: South Punjab and Sindh:
The debate is not abstract. It is deeply regional.
In Punjab, there is broad political sympathy for South Punjab province. In Sindh, the proposal to divide the province has met strong opposition, with the Sindh Assembly already passing a resolution against division.
That is exactly why Article 239(4) exists. A nationwide referendum could show majority support for new provinces in general, but it cannot override the specific constitutional protection given to the province being divided.
Any honest column must say this plainly: You cannot use a national referendum to bypass a provincial assembly.
If the government wants new provinces, it must do the hard work build consensus in the affected provinces, secure two thirds in the provincial assemblies, secure two thirds in Parliament, and then amend the Constitution.
What Should Happen Next?
1. Be honest about the law: The government should tell the public that a referendum is consultative, not constitutive.
2. Define the question: “Do you want new provinces?” is too vague. Which provinces? With what boundaries? With what capitals, resources, and water shares?
3. Respect the provinces: No province should be divided without its own assembly’s consent.
4. Follow the amendment route: After a referendum, if there is public support, the government must still bring a proper constitutional amendment under Article 239.
Pakistan does not need more provinces created by confusion. It needs provinces created by consent, by law, and by the will of the people who will live in them.
Article 48 can start that conversation. Only Article 239 can finish it.
We welcome your contributions! Submit your blogs, opinion pieces, press releases, news story pitches, and news features to opinion@minutemirror.com.pk and minutemirrormail@gmail.com

