Summary
- On the map that divides Sindh into three provinces, a farmer in Badin could elect a government in Karachi, while the water for his fields would begin its journey at Sukkur, two provincial boundaries away.
- I would still want to know whether he can get water into my canal.
- He needs an agreement that says how much water must pass the provincial boundary this week, and an officer who can enforce it on Wednesday.
Eleven of Sidhnai Barrage’s fifteen bays lie in Khanewal district and four in Toba Tek Singh. Today, one irrigation department operates all fifteen. Under the proposals now circulating in public debate, Punjab would be divided into four provinces. On that map, the boundary between Southern and Central Punjab runs through the barrage itself. When the Ravi rises in the middle of the night, whose order would the officer at Sidhnai obey?
Follow the Rohri Canal from Sukkur to Badin and the question looks different. On the map that divides Sindh into three provinces, a farmer in Badin could elect a government in Karachi, while the water for his fields would begin its journey at Sukkur, two provincial boundaries away. If his irrigation turn passed without water, which government could put it right in time to save his crop?
I have long supported the creation of South Punjab. Having represented its people and served as Punjab’s irrigation minister, I understand what it costs a district when decisions about its future are taken far away. As a tail-end farmer, I also know the limits of bringing the provincial capital closer. My new irrigation secretary may be within driving distance. I would still want to know whether he can get water into my canal.
The debate has found room for the location of capitals, representation in the Senate and the division of revenues. Water deserves at least as much attention. A provincial government can spend its share of a financial transfer once the money reaches its account. To deliver a share of water, someone must operate a gate on a particular day, sometimes a considerable distance outside the province that needs it.
Long before Partition, Punjab’s Triple Canal Project carried Jhelum water into the Chenab and supplies onwards to the Ravi. In 1947, the Radcliffe Line left the Madhopur and Ferozepore headworks in India, while some of the canals they supplied continued to irrigate fields in Pakistan. On 1 April 1948, after temporary arrangements expired, supplies to some of those canals stopped. The farmers worked the same land. The channels still reached their fields. What had changed was who controlled the gates.
Consider the Lower Bari Doab Canal. It takes off at Balloki, which the proposed map places in Northeastern Punjab. It irrigates Okara and Sahiwal in the proposed Central Punjab and reaches Khanewal in Southern Punjab. Suppose the gates at Balloki need repairs just as farmers in Sahiwal need water for sowing. At present one department can weigh the risks and set the closure. Under the proposal, the government at Balloki might authorise the work, another would answer to the farmers facing a delay, and a third would have an interest in when the canal reopened.
A barrage is not a title deed to the water passing through it.
When Sukkur Barrage opened in 1932, farmers far downstream gained a more dependable supply. Today the proposed boundaries would cut across an inequality farmers already live with. In some head reaches, excessive watering and poor drainage leave land waterlogged. Farther down the same system, a farmer can wait through his turn and receive too little to irrigate the field he has sown. Today he can press the department operating the canal to enforce the rotation. Imagine his position if the officer who hears his complaint must first persuade another provincial government to release the water.
Nor does the dependence end at the last farm. Under the proposal, a Coastal Sindh would answer for Karachi’s drinking water and the Indus Delta, yet hold no major barrage. Guddu and Sukkur would sit in Northern Sindh; Kotri in Central Sindh. Sindh knows what it means to wait on upstream releases, and Balochistan knows what it means to wait on Sindh. IRSA has already recorded the reality of this tail-end frustration: an agreed 10,300 cusecs for Balochistan’s canals, against just 7,608 actually supplied. When officials from the two provinces recently disagreed before a parliamentary committee over where to install gauges on the Pat Feeder, the dispute was not about theory. It was about whether a farmer’s share is measured when it leaves, or when it arrives.
Punjab knows that frustration too. On the Chashma Right Bank Canal, farmers around Taunsa depend on water that passes through Khyper Pakhtunkhwa. In August 2026, the Indus River System Authority called a meeting over the shortfall in Punjab’s authorised supply at Ramak. A province commonly thought of as upstream on the Indus can find itself at the tail of a canal. The farmer there has much in common with the farmer in Badin.
The 1991 Water Apportionment Accord gives us somewhere to begin. It assigns shares to the existing provinces, and its ten-daily schedules identify supplies for individual canal systems. Those schedules establish what a canal should receive. They cannot dictate how three governments will divide the water in the Lower Bari Doab Canal during a dry fortnight. Suppose the farmer in Khanewal is due his turn on Thursday. If the upstream province takes its usual supply on Monday and Tuesday and the shortage falls entirely on the tail by Thursday, a seasonal account may tell him months later what he already knows. He needs an agreement that says how much water must pass the provincial boundary this week, and an officer who can enforce it on Wednesday.
Haryana’s experience shows how long a farmer can wait for an agreement to be carried out. Sixty years after Haryana was carved out of Indian Punjab, the Sutlej–Yamuna Link intended to help deliver its full share of the Ravi–Beas waters remains unfinished. The quantity was settled in 1981. The water is still waiting.
Before Parliament votes on new boundaries, the public must see the water arrangements alongside the map. The requirements are mechanical, not magical: name the authority that will operate cross-border canals; fix the exact measurement points for every provincial delivery; and publish the shortage-sharing rules before the first dry fortnight. Settle maintenance liabilities, grant emergency repair powers, and finally fix the numeric freshwater floor below Kotri. Give a named authority the power to enforce a delivery within the irrigation turn. A legal ruling delivered after the harvest may prove the farmer was right; by then, his crop is dead and his family is in debt.
A constitution can be amended in a week. A water dispute can take sixty years. A farmer in Badin should know who must deliver his water. The officer at Sidhnai should know whose order to obey. Before drawing the boundaries, decide who will open the gates.
We welcome your contributions! Submit your blogs, opinion pieces, press releases, news story pitches, and news features to opinion@minutemirror.com.pk and minutemirrormail@gmail.com

