Summary
- More than two decades later, Pakistan’s Planning Commission appears to have watched that movie, missed the punchline entirely, and turned it into official government policy.
- While New Delhi traded obsolete planning boards for think tanks driven by domain experts, Pakistan’s Planning Commission looked at a multi-billion-dollar hydropower crisis, handed over the stethoscope, and whispered: “Take two aspirins and call us when the dam stops leaking.” Of course, the laughter starts to fade—and turns into a cold sweat—when you remember what this chair at the Planning Commission actually represents.
- The doctor has finally been discharged from the Planning Commission, yet Pakistan’s mega-projects remain in the intensive care unit.
In 2003, Bollywood released the comedy classic Munna Bhai M.B.B.S., in which a lovable street rogue bluffs his way into medical school and treats critically ill patients with warm hugs instead of actual medicine. Audiences across South Asia laughed until their sides hurt because the premise was gloriously absurd. Nobody in their right mind would ever let an unqualified amateur run a hospital ward. More than two decades later, Pakistan’s Planning Commission appears to have watched that movie, missed the punchline entirely, and turned it into official government policy. While India made Munna Bhai M.B.B.S. on a cinema screen, Islamabad proudly launched the reverse sequel: Dr. Bhai, Chief Hydraulic Engineer.
What made this situation worthy of a standing ovation at a comedy club was who signed the prescription. Pakistan’s Minister for Planning, Ahsan Iqbal, is an engineer himself. He knows the difference between a structural blueprint and a blood test, and between a spillway and a spleen. Yet, when it came time to appoint the Member for Implementation and Monitoring—the senior official responsible for watching over billion-dollar hydropower projects, power plants, and underground tunnels—the engineer minister looked past every civil, mechanical, and electrical engineer in the country and selected Dr. Awais-e-Siraj, a medical doctor.
One can only imagine the magic that unfolded in that Islamabad interview room.
For decades, experienced engineers have walked into the Planning Commission lugging thick binders full of intimidating math, concrete stress tables, water-pressure formulas, and geological fault surveys. It is dry, heavy, migraine-inducing stuff. Then in strolled Dr. Awais-e-Siraj, armed with a stethoscope, an M.B.B.S. degree, and a resume from hospital administration. Before arriving at the Planning Commission, he served as Chief Executive Officer of Novocare International Hospital in Sargodha and as CEO of the CHAL Foundation, a respected organization that helps physically challenged citizens live active, contributing lives.
To a weary government selection committee desperate to get stalled infrastructure projects moving, that resume must have read like divine intervention. In Urdu, “Chal” means “let’s go” or “move.” One can almost hear the interview panel whispering to each other in breathless excitement: “Look at his CV! He ran CHAL! If he can make CHAL work, he can definitely make Pakistan’s stalled power projects chal again!” Who needs thirty years of experience in dam construction when you have the right Urdu verb printed on your letterhead? By that logic, our next Minister for Aviation should be the CEO of Uraan, and the head of the Federal Board of Revenue should be a guy who used to manage a bakery called Dough.
And honestly, once you took off your hard hat, put on a white lab coat, and examined Pakistan’s hydropower disasters through the eyes of a general physician, everything suddenly made complete sense.
Take the Neelum–Jhelum Hydropower Plant near Muzaffarabad. This massive 969-megawatt project has been nothing short of an engineering tragedy. In July 2022, its Tail Race Tunnel collapsed, halting electricity generation. After costly repairs, even worse structural failures appeared in the head-race tunnel, forcing a complete shutdown in May 2024 that has left the plant silent ever since. Traditional engineers look at Neelum–Jhelum and see a terrifying puzzle of shifting Himalayan fault lines, crushing mountain rock, and flawed concrete lining.
A medical doctor, however, takes one look at a blocked Tail Race Tunnel, taps his clipboard, and diagnoses it for what it obviously is: a stubborn urinary tract infection. Why waste millions of dollars on geotechnical consultants and tunnel-boring specialists when you can treat a blocked outflow pipe the exact same way you treat a patient on Ward 4? You simply prescribe plenty of fluids, put the Jhelum River on a seven-day course of broad-spectrum antibiotics, insert a giant concrete catheter, and wait patiently for the discharge to clear up. If the hydraulic pressure spikes again at night, just tell the mountain to take two Panadols, drink warm water, and call the ministry in the morning.
The exact same clinical brilliance applied to the Tarbela 5th Extension Hydropower Project (T5HP), WAPDA’s flagship clean-energy expansion on the Indus River. On November 9, 2026, disaster struck when a weak rock mass collapsed at the T-5 construction site during tunnel excavation, sending a violent surge of water from the intake pit rushing into nearby work areas and inflicting yet another multi-billion-rupee blow on Pakistan’s battered economy. While hydraulic engineers tore their hair out over rock-bolting, slope stability, and underground seepage, someone who used to oversee abdominal surgeries in Sargodha knew not to break a sweat.
In a hospital operating theatre, a sudden internal rupture during surgery is just another Tuesday. You yell “Scalpel! Suction! Clamps!”, stitch up the torn tissue, check the vitals, and wheel the patient into the recovery room. Why bother with complicated geological modeling when you can treat a collapsing mountainside on the Indus River like a ruptured appendix? Just put Tarbela on strict bed rest, restrict the powerhouse to a diet of clear liquids, hang an IV drip of PSDP funds from a crane, and ban all visitors from the turbine hall until the stitches heal.
To truly appreciate the comedy of errors unfolding in Islamabad, one only has to look across the border at India’s masterclass in administrative housekeeping. In 2014, Prime Minister Narendra Modi—often proudly evoking his humble beginnings as a tea seller (chaiwala)—did something radical: he abolished India’s Planning Commission entirely, replacing it with NITI Aayog. While critics argued about politics, Modi’s underlying diagnosis was pure economic common sense: the old Soviet-style Planning Commission had become a bloated relic of red tape, bureaucratic daydreaming, and political appointments where people with zero domain expertise sat around deciding the fate of national infrastructure. Modi realized that running a modern economy requires actual specialists, technocrats, and data-driven execution—not a committee of generalists playing administrative roulette.
Meanwhile, back in Pakistan, the Planning Commission did not just survive the 21st century; it evolved. Instead of abolishing the bureaucratic graveyard, Islamabad decided to staff it with an actual physician to perform surgery on broken tunnels. Perhaps Modi’s tea-stalling days gave him a sharper eye for brewing common sense than an engineering minister holding a prestigious degree. While New Delhi traded obsolete planning boards for think tanks driven by domain experts, Pakistan’s Planning Commission looked at a multi-billion-dollar hydropower crisis, handed over the stethoscope, and whispered: “Take two aspirins and call us when the dam stops leaking.”
Of course, the laughter starts to fade—and turns into a cold sweat—when you remember what this chair at the Planning Commission actually represents.
Historically, the Member for Implementation and Monitoring was never a parking spot for lateral thinkers or motivational healers. It was occupied by some of the toughest, most deeply learned engineers in Pakistan—men who had spent their entire lives building, testing, and defending critical national infrastructure. Think of figures like General Shahid Niaz, the former Engineer-in-Chief of the Pakistan Army, who brought decades of hard-won command experience in heavy civil engineering, logistics, and mega-project execution to the table. When a tunnel cracked or a dam fell behind schedule under watchdogs of that caliber, contractors trembled because the man sitting across the table knew every calculation, every cubic meter of concrete, and every excuse in the book. You could not bluff him with bedside manner.
Fittingly, on November 10, 2026—just twenty-four hours after the Tarbela T-5 tunnel collapse—Ahsan Iqbal finally pulled the plug on the experiment and showed this medical practitioner the door. After two years of watching mega-projects bleed while a physician held the clipboard, the engineer minister suddenly remembered that you cannot cure a fractured mountainside with a stethoscope.
The laws of physics, after all, did not go to medical school and have zero respect for bedside manner. Millions of tons of Himalayan rock pressing down on a concrete tunnel will not soften because a doctor leans in and asks how it is feeling today. A roaring river surging through an excavation shaft at Tarbela cannot be calmed down with a reassuring pat on the shoulder, a prescription pad from Sargodha, or a jadoo ki jhappi. Engineering failures demand rigorous science, honest accountability, and deep technical mastery—not a change of hospital gown.
The doctor has finally been discharged from the Planning Commission, yet Pakistan’s mega-projects remain in the intensive care unit. Let’s just hope that whoever steps into the ward next brings a hard hat and a structural blueprint—because after two years of hospital-based hydropower, our dams cannot survive another round of malpractice.
We welcome your contributions! Submit your blogs, opinion pieces, press releases, news story pitches, and news features to opinion@minutemirror.com.pk and minutemirrormail@gmail.com
