Summary
- Pakistan delivered the criticism during a United Nations Security Council meeting on natural resources and conflict prevention, where it accused New Delhi of attempting to use shared water resources as a tool of political pressure.
- Jadoon specifically accused India of threatening Pakistan’s water security by placing the Indus Waters Treaty in abeyance and signalling possible restrictions on river flows.
- The exchange at the United Nations highlighted the growing diplomatic confrontation between Pakistan and India over the Indus Waters Treaty, which regulates the distribution and use of water from the Indus river system.
Pakistan has strongly criticised India’s unilateral decision to suspend the Indus Waters Treaty, describing the move as “outlaw behaviour” and warning that it threatens the water security of more than 240 million people and could further escalate tensions between the two nuclear-armed neighbours.
Pakistan delivered the criticism during a United Nations Security Council meeting on natural resources and conflict prevention, where it accused New Delhi of attempting to use shared water resources as a tool of political pressure.
First Secretary Ansar Shah, exercising Pakistan’s right of reply to remarks by the Indian representative, said India could not unilaterally decide when the 1960 treaty would remain applicable or determine the conditions for its implementation.
“That is not treaty law; it is outlaw behaviour,” Shah said, rejecting India’s justification for placing the agreement in abeyance.
He warned that using water as a weapon against Pakistan was not a reassessment of the agreement but an act of coercion that could create conditions for conflict.
Pakistan’s position was initially presented by its Deputy Permanent Representative to the UN, Ambassador Usman Jadoon, during an Arria-formula meeting convened by Liberia on November 18. The meeting focused on the role of natural resources in conflict prevention and peacebuilding.
Addressing the gathering, Jadoon said natural resources should promote sustainable development, shared prosperity and regional stability rather than become instruments of exploitation and conflict.
He highlighted the challenges faced by resource-rich developing countries, citing the Democratic Republic of Congo, where extensive mineral reserves had contributed to prolonged instability instead of improving living conditions.
Jadoon identified three priorities for preventing resource-related conflicts: addressing political and governance weaknesses, tackling illicit financial flows through international cooperation and ensuring that developing countries benefit from investment, technology transfer and local processing.
He also stressed that responsibility for preventing illegal resource exploitation should extend beyond producing countries to transit states, consuming nations, multinational companies and financial institutions.
Discussing shared water resources, the Pakistani diplomat said neighbouring countries must respect international law, honour existing agreements and resolve disputes through peaceful mechanisms.
He referred to UN Security Council Resolution 2788 and Article 33 of the UN Charter, which emphasise peaceful settlement of international disputes.
Jadoon specifically accused India of threatening Pakistan’s water security by placing the Indus Waters Treaty in abeyance and signalling possible restrictions on river flows.
He also referred to an August 31 ruling by the Court of Arbitration in the Indus Waters dispute, which affirmed that the treaty remained in force and that India continued to be bound by its obligations. The court also rejected India’s stated grounds for suspending or terminating the agreement.
Responding to Pakistan’s intervention, India’s Permanent Representative to the UN, Ambassador Harish Parvathaneni, defended the use of existing international mechanisms to address disputes involving natural resources.
He cited the Kimberley Process, an international initiative aimed at preventing the trade in conflict diamonds while protecting legitimate commerce, as an example of effective cooperation.
In his subsequent right of reply, Shah accused the Indian representative of avoiding the central issue and resorting to deflection rather than addressing the treaty dispute.
He maintained that the 1960 agreement contained no provision allowing either country to suspend its implementation unilaterally.
Responding to India’s argument that circumstances had changed since the treaty was signed, Shah questioned whether New Delhi also considered the United Nations Charter outdated because it was established earlier.
He further accused India of disregarding Security Council resolutions on Jammu and Kashmir and alleged that Indian forces had killed more than 100,000 Kashmiris since 1989 while denying them their fundamental rights and right to self-determination.
Shah also rejected India’s comments on Pakistan’s internal political affairs, describing the country as a constitutional democracy where citizens had the right to elect their representatives and exercise fundamental freedoms.
He, in turn, accused India’s ruling Hindutva establishment of promoting discrimination against minorities, restricting freedom of expression and encouraging religious hostility.
Calling on New Delhi to respect international law, Shah urged the Indian government to abandon what he described as its “hubris” and fulfil its obligations under international agreements and Security Council resolutions.
The exchange at the United Nations highlighted the growing diplomatic confrontation between Pakistan and India over the Indus Waters Treaty, which regulates the distribution and use of water from the Indus river system.
Signed in 1960 with the World Bank’s involvement, the agreement allocated the eastern rivers — Ravi, Beas and Sutlej — primarily to India, while granting Pakistan rights over the western rivers — Indus, Jhelum and Chenab — subject to specified provisions allowing India certain uses.
We welcome your contributions! Submit your blogs, opinion pieces, press releases, news story pitches, and news features to opinion@minutemirror.com.pk and minutemirrormail@gmail.com

