REIMAGINING SINDH, A NEW POLITICAL DIRECTION AND ADMINISTRATIVE AUTONOMY FOR KARACHI

Dr. Abdul Mateen Sheikh
By
Dr. Abdul Mateen Sheikh
Dr. Abdul Mateen Shaikh is a healthcare professional, Diabetes education trainer, research scholar, management consultant and columnist with 18 years of experience in pharmacy practice, diabetes...
13 Min Read

Summary

  • An Alternative Political Platform for Sindh and Administrative Autonomy for Karachi Are the Need of the Hour The debate over the creation of new provinces, administrative restructuring and the devolution of powers to lower levels of government has once again gained momentum in Pakistan.
  • Its political base would be interior Sindh, and its manifesto would focus on public welfare, education, healthcare, employment, industrial development, merit and economic self-reliance rather than the traditional practices of feudal politics.
  • Serious dialogue should begin on creating alternative democratic leadership for the economic and political development of interior Sindh, alongside an empowered administrative structure for Karachi.
AI Generated Summary

An Alternative Political Platform for Sindh and Administrative Autonomy for Karachi Are the Need of the Hour

The debate over the creation of new provinces, administrative restructuring and the devolution of powers to lower levels of government has once again gained momentum in Pakistan. While different opinions are emerging across the country, the issue is viewed with particular political sensitivity in Sindh. The fundamental question is whether proposing administrative restructuring of a province necessarily amounts to challenging its unity, culture or identity. Or is it possible that administrative reforms could instead provide the province’s deprived communities with their long-denied fundamental rights?

In my view, the time has come to examine Sindh’s challenges through the lens of ground realities, public needs and administrative performance rather than emotional slogans.

The bigger political party of sindh has maintained political dominance and governed Sindh for several decades. Despite this prolonged period in power, numerous areas of interior Sindh continue to struggle with poverty, unemployment, underdevelopment, inadequate educational facilities, poor healthcare and the absence of essential public services. Consider districts and towns such as Kandhkot, Ghotki, Kashmore, Bhirya road, Naushehro feroz, Shahdad poor, Shah poor chakar, Tharparkar, Chachro, Diplo, Mithi, Mirwah, Digri, Tando Jan Muhammad, Khairpur, Tandoalayar, Naukot, Dadu, Sehwan, Larkana and Qambar etc. Why do their residents still face difficulties accessing quality education, modern healthcare facilities and adequate employment opportunities?

Why has industrial development failed to take root across interior Sindh? Why have large-scale industrial zones, factories and commercial centers not been established? Why have sufficient efforts not been made to develop technical training institutions, modern universities and employment opportunities that could enable local economies to become self-sustaining? The best way to develop a society is not to make it permanently dependent on financial assistance, but to empower its people through employment, skills, education and economic independence.

Social protection initiatives such as the Benazir Income Support Programme (BISP) are undoubtedly important for genuinely deserving families. However, an important question remains: Can financial assistance alone provide a permanent solution to poverty? Can a few thousand rupees a month replace a young person’s future, a family’s economic independence or the industrial development of an entire region? 

The real success of a government will come when deserving families, no longer have to wait for financial assistance to survive, but instead have at least one member earning a respectable livelihood. Alongside social protection, the government must create employment opportunities, promote vocational training and encourage entrepreneurship.

FEUDAL POLITICS AND THE NEED FOR AN ALTERNATIVE POLITICAL PATH

One of the defining features of Sindh’s political landscape is the influence of feudalism and powerful local political structures. The bigger political party of Sindh includes numerous influential political families and personalities whose political strength is widely perceived to be rooted, to a considerable extent, in their family backgrounds, tribal affiliations and feudal influence within their respective constituencies. Basically this big party is based on electable, its power is its electable members. 

An important question therefore deserves consideration, are all these political figures necessarily affiliated with this bigger party because of their commitment to its ideology or the political philosophy of the founder and former (Late) PM? Or do some view the party’s platform as a means of preserving and expanding their political and regional influence?

At this point, I would like to present an alternative political proposal for consideration by Pakistan’s powerful decision-makers, political strategists and influential circles involved in shaping the country’s administrative and political affairs.

Why not consider establishing a new political party specifically representing interior Sindh, tentatively named the “Sindh Awami Ittihad”. Its political base would be interior Sindh, and its manifesto would focus on public welfare, education, healthcare, employment, industrial development, merit and economic self-reliance rather than the traditional practices of feudal politics. Under this proposal, influential landlords, agricultural elites and established political families currently associated with existing political parties could be invited to join a new political platform. They should be encouraged to utilize their political capabilities, local influence and electoral strength not merely to acquire political power but to contribute meaningfully to the development of their respective regions. They could contest elections in their own constituencies, present their manifestos before the electorate and seek public support through democratic means to form a government. However, a fundamental condition of this proposed political platform must be that no individual enjoys political privilege merely because of their family background or feudal status. Political legitimacy must be determined by performance, public accountability, transparency and merit.

If influential political personalities from interior Sindh unite under an alternative political platform, a new political force could emerge, presenting a genuine democratic challenge to the bigger political party’s existing political dominance. This is not a proposal to eliminate any political party through undemocratic means. Rather, it is a proposal to encourage political competition and create an alternative avenue for democratic representation and leadership for interior Sindh and their people, as they are deprived from their essential rights since decades.

KARACHI MUST BE GIVEN THE AUTHORITY TO DECIDE ITS OWN FUTURE

Karachi is not merely the capital of Sindh, it is Pakistan’s economic, industrial and commercial powerhouse, with an international identity. Its seaport, industries, commercial centers, tax revenues and human resources play a fundamental role in sustaining the national economy.

Yet what is the present condition of this city?

Shortages of clean drinking water, dependence on water tankers, deteriorating roads, chaotic traffic, encroachments, drainage problems, excessive electricity bills, law-and-order concerns and street crime have made everyday life increasingly difficult for its residents. Citizens often feel unsafe even when carrying their mobile phones, cash or personal vehicles. On one hand, the city’s economic significance is recognized internationally, on the other, its residents continue to struggle for basic civic amenities.

Should Karachi’s situation remain unchanged indefinitely?

I propose that the possibility of granting Karachi the status of a separate, fully empowered administrative province be examined seriously, impartially and within the constitutional framework. The people of Karachi must have meaningful authority over the administration of their city, its resources, development projects, civic facilities and future direction. Karachi is home to Pakistanis belonging to different linguistic, cultural and regional communities. Urdu-speaking residents, Sindhis, Baloch, Pashtuns, Punjabis, Kashmiris and many other communities are all contributing to the city’s development.

Administrative autonomy for Karachi must not be presented as a project belonging to any particular language or ethnic community. It should be a project designed to secure a better future for every Pakistani living in this city. Similarly, major urban centers such as Hyderabad and Mirpurkhas should also be empowered through strong, accountable local governments, giving them meaningful authority over their administrative and development affairs.

The Quota System, Merit and Equal Opportunities

Another important issue is the quota system. The existing arrangements for representation in government employment and educational institutions need to be reviewed. The purpose of any such system should be to ensure equal opportunities and genuine merit, not to create or perpetuate permanent disadvantage. Young people from both urban and rural Sindh must have fair opportunities to progress through transparent and competitive selection processes. No young person’s future should be determined by their geographical background, language, family connections or political affiliations.

This Is a Question of Administrative Reform, Not Division, it is very much clear

It must be clearly understood that respecting Sindh’s culture, history, language and identity is the responsibility of every Pakistani. The Sindhi topi, Ajrak, Sindhi language and the thousands of years of civilization associated with this region are valuable cultural assets. Respecting these traditions and advocating administrative reforms are not contradictory positions. But, are these traditional things, emotional slogans, ethnicity, linguistic speeches can fulfil the living requirements? Can these provide good education? Can these are enough to run their kitchens? Can these things be fulfilling the requirement of good health facilities, safety of people, protection of their assets, economy of the interior Sindh’s people?

The question is not who is Sindhi and who is non-Sindhi. The real question is why all citizens living in Sindh are still struggling to obtain clean drinking water, quality education, healthcare, employment, security and the opportunity to live with dignity. When a citizen travels on a road, its damaged condition does not distinguish between ethnicities. When someone becomes a victim of street crime, the criminal does not ask about their language or ethnic background before snatching their mobile phone. The problems are shared by everyone, therefore, their solutions must also be collective. Pakistan’s powerful decision-makers, political leadership and constitutional institutions should take this entire debate beyond emotional politics and transform it into a practical policy framework. Serious dialogue should begin on creating alternative democratic leadership for the economic and political development of interior Sindh, alongside an empowered administrative structure for Karachi.

The creation of new provinces must take place in accordance with the constitutional procedures established under the Constitution of Pakistan, including the required approval of the relevant provincial assembly and national consensus.  The people’s opinion never be ignored when making any major administrative, political, or constitutional decision. If the people of a particular region wish to express their views regarding their future, administrative status, or the establishment of a new province, they should be given that opportunity.

A referendum is a democratic means of seeking public opinion, and Articles of the Constitution of Pakistan provide the constitutional basis and legal framework for it. Therefore, such sensitive matters should be addressed through constitutional and democratic means rather than through political opposition or support. The people must be taken into confidence and provided with an opportunity to express their views freely in an independent, transparent, and impartial environment. Ultimately, the fundamental principle of democracy is that the people’s voices must be given due importance in decisions concerning their future.

Finally, my question is simple: Should the people of Sindh be left to spend another several decades relying on political slogans, deprivation and unfulfilled promises? Or should they be provided with a system in which their children receive quality education, young people have employment opportunities, families enjoy security and every citizen has the right to live with dignity?

Sindh does not need decisions against anyone, it needs decisions in favor of its people. Karachi needs authority, interior Sindh needs development, and Pakistan needs a stronger, empowered and accountable administrative system.

Because Pakistan’s strength does not lie in the deprivation of its provinces, but in the prosperity of their people.

We welcome your contributions! Submit your blogs, opinion pieces, press releases, news story pitches, and news features to opinion@minutemirror.com.pk and minutemirrormail@gmail.com
Share This Article
Dr. Abdul Mateen Shaikh is a healthcare professional, Diabetes education trainer, research scholar, management consultant and columnist with 18 years of experience in pharmacy practice, diabetes prevention programs, hospital management, and patient safety. Through his writings, he highlights public health challenges, social issues, moral values, current affairs and healthcare reforms in Pakistan
Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *