Summary
- Before they commit their money and labour to another crop, the government should answer a question left unsettled by the last harvest: will the families growing the province’s food receive the same concern as those struggling to buy it?
- During the last wheat harvest, the government announced a benchmark of Rs3,500 per 40 kilograms, but the private aggregator system failed to procure at scale.
- By early October, open-market prices were reportedly around Rs5,300 per 40 kilograms.
Punjab’s farmers are preparing to sow wheat again. Before they commit their money and labour to another crop, the government should answer a question left unsettled by the last harvest: will the families growing the province’s food receive the same concern as those struggling to buy it?
In October, rising flour prices prompted a Rs10 billion relief package and expanded subsidised wheat supplies to mills. Earlier, when growers faced disappointing harvest prices, many were left to manage the consequences within their own households.
The rise in a family’s food bill brought government into the market. The fall in a cultivator’s earnings too often left him alone with his creditors.
Assistance for consumers was necessary. But fairness requires us to consider the circumstances of those whose losses attracted less urgent attention.
The Pakistan Economic Survey 2025–26 puts rural poverty at 36.2 per cent, against 17.4 per cent in urban areas. Poverty is more than twice as prevalent in the countryside. With approximately three-fifths of Pakistanis living outside cities, roughly three-quarters of the country’s poor live there.
Punjab’s poverty rate has also deteriorated, rising from 16.5 per cent in 2018–19 to 23.3 per cent in 2024–25. Nearly a quarter of the province’s population lives below the national poverty line.
These figures place agricultural policy among communities with widespread deprivation and limited capacity to withstand financial setbacks. Their vulnerability deserves a place in decisions about who receives public protection.
Yet the poorer grower can disappear from view behind the familiar image of the prosperous landowner. Agriculture has influential representatives, so the assumption follows that agricultural households can look after themselves.
A small cultivator borrowing for seed and fertiliser inhabits a different economy from an owner able to finance the season comfortably. The first may have to accept whatever price is available when repayment falls due. The second can consider his options.
Their shared occupation should not conceal their unequal means.
During the last wheat harvest, the government announced a benchmark of Rs3,500 per 40 kilograms, but the private aggregator system failed to procure at scale. Early sellers in South Punjab reportedly received around Rs3,000 per 40 kilograms. By early October, open-market prices were reportedly around Rs5,300 per 40 kilograms. The farmer who had already parted with his grain could not benefit from that recovery.
Officials later maintained that aggregators still had time to supply stocks from September onwards. But a reserve built in September cannot repay a loss incurred in April.
The October intervention, by contrast, increased subsidised supplies to mills at Rs3,800 per 40 kilograms, with the stated purpose of passing the benefit to flour buyers. Government recognised that households needed protection from prices they could not afford.
The grower’s earlier predicament deserved an equally practical response.
I farm in South Punjab, and I have made these calculations myself. Harvest income arrives with several claims already attached. The fertiliser dealer expects payment. The arhti, the commission agent who often finances the crop, has an account to settle. Labour and household expenses cannot simply be suspended.
When receipts disappoint, the farmer pays what he can. Some debt remains outstanding. A purchase is postponed. An expense intended for the family is redirected towards cultivation. Another loan may be needed before the next season begins.
His loss enters a ledger rather than a television headline.
The family continues working, and the fields are prepared again. To someone passing through, rural life appears unchanged. Within the household, however, there is less room for illness, an unexpected expense or another disappointing crop.
The consequences of one harvest enter the next before the government’s attention returns to sowing targets.
That is where unequal urgency becomes consequential. Rising flour prices are immediately visible at shops and tandoors. Complaints can be recorded, prices compared and officials asked what they intend to do.
A cultivator’s reduced earnings are scattered across villages and private accounts. There may be no crowd, no queue and no single location where the cumulative hardship can be photographed. Each household makes its own accommodations, allowing a widespread problem to appear as a collection of individual difficulties.
The absence of a spectacle should not diminish the claim to assistance.
Food insecurity makes that claim more pressing. The Pakistan Bureau of Statistics reports that 26.7 per cent of rural households experienced moderate or severe food insecurity in 2024–25, compared with 20.6 per cent of urban households.
Living among fields offers no automatic protection against difficulty obtaining food. Labourers may own no land. Tenants receive only a share of what they cultivate. Smallholders may have insufficient produce or income to sustain their families throughout the year.
A household can sell grain because repayment cannot wait, then purchase food when its own supplies prove insufficient. The person who appears in policy discussions as a producer may also need protection as a consumer.
Government should recognise his vulnerability throughout that cycle.
The approaching sowing season makes this an immediate policy question. Farmers must decide what they can afford to spend on land preparation, seed, fertiliser and irrigation. Much of that expenditure will be committed long before anyone knows the harvest price.
They are being asked to accept months of uncertainty in order to deliver an essential food crop. Government should reduce the uncertainty it can control.
Any announced wheat price must therefore be accompanied by a clear account of its meaning. Who will buy at that price? Which farmers will qualify? Where will purchases take place? What quantities are covered, and when will payment reach the seller?
These details determine whether an announcement offers practical protection or merely raises expectations.
The arrangements should be understood before sowing, rather than clarified after families have invested. Assistance with cultivation costs should reach eligible growers when those costs arise. Purchasing systems must be accessible to smaller farmers, including those who cannot navigate repeated registrations, journeys and official requirements.
Affordable credit and usable storage can also provide room to make a less desperate selling decision. But farmers need arrangements that work in their circumstances, rather than facilities whose existence is easier to announce than to use.
Punjab need not restore every feature of its former procurement system. Expensive public operations require reform, and government cannot undertake to cover every commercial loss. It can, however, ensure that poorer growers are not expected to bear the entire burden of an uncertain transition.
The test of fairness is whether public policy recognises vulnerability on both sides of the food economy. A family unable to afford bread requires help. A family unable to recover the reasonable costs of growing wheat also merits attention.
Consumer relief should not become a reason to overlook producer hardship, nor should support for growers disregard those who must buy their food. A responsible government has obligations to both.
This season, those obligations should be made concrete before the seed enters the soil.
Punjab depends on farmers to finance, cultivate and deliver its next wheat harvest. It should offer its poorer growers a dependable basis on which to undertake that responsibility.
The province cannot ask them to secure everyone else’s food while leaving the security of their own households an afterthought.
We welcome your contributions! Submit your blogs, opinion pieces, press releases, news story pitches, and news features to opinion@minutemirror.com.pk and minutemirrormail@gmail.com

