The taxpayer’s missing scorecard

Dr. Ikramul Haq
By
Dr. Ikramul Haq
Dr. Ikramul Haq, Advocate Supreme Court, specialises in constitutional, corporate, media, ML/CFT related laws, IT, intellectual property, arbitration and international tax laws. He is country editor...
10 Min Read

Summary

  • That question runs through Muhammad Ashraf and Muhammad Yousha’s paper, Focus on Federal Board of Revenue: Evolutionary Reorganization or Restructuring. The authors take seriously what another upheaval means for officers who have invested a career in learning their work.
  • On November 15, 2026, daily Dawn reported that sales tax and federal excise would have dedicated oversight at the Board and that separate sales tax teams would operate from commissioner level down.
  • FBR should be able to count that outcome too.  Muhammad Ashraf and Muhammad Yousha, Focus on Federal Board of Revenue: Evolutionary Reorganization or Restructuring, November 2026.
AI Generated Summary

Consider a manufacturer who has explained a difference between two returns. The income tax officer accepts the reconciliation. A month later, a sales tax officer asks for the same invoices. Both officers may be doing their jobs conscientiously. Both may record a case processed. The manufacturer has paid an accountant twice to explain one set of books. Which of the three would say that the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) has become more efficient?

That question runs through Muhammad Ashraf and Muhammad Yousha’s paper, Focus on Federal Board of Revenue: Evolutionary Reorganization or Restructuring. The authors take seriously what another upheaval means for officers who have invested a career in learning their work. They also make room for the citizen at the receiving end. Their strongest proposal is to measure how much time and money people spend fulfilling their tax obligations. Applied to the government’s latest decision on sales tax, that measure could tell a rather different story from the one told at headquarters.

On November 15, 2026, daily Dawn reported that sales tax and federal excise would have dedicated oversight at the Board and that separate sales tax teams would operate from commissioner level down. Chief commissioners would retain administrative control and the officers would remain within the Inland Revenue Service. Officials cited an estimated sales tax gap of Rs. 3.4 trillion.

The official figure establishes the scale of the problem as officials understand it. It tells the public very little about how much of the gap arose because the same field formation administered income tax and sales tax. Seventeen years after integration, the government owes Parliament an account of what went wrong before it spends public money undoing part of the arrangement.

There is a respectable case for specialisation. An officer investigating a chain of fictitious input claims needs to understand invoices, stock movements and the businesses through which the claims travelled. A transfer-pricing examination calls for different expertise.

Ashraf and Yousha sagaciously propose specialist career paths so that a capable officer can advance while continuing to do the work he or she knows. Where the government’s reasoning needs scrutiny is the leap from specialist knowledge to separate jurisdictions. A sales tax specialist can examine a difficult transaction within an integrated team. A separate commissionerate acquires its own caseload, correspondence and reasons for pursuing the taxpayer. The two arrangements carry different costs for the person who must answer.

The paper’s historical account would gain much from asking why earlier changes fell short. It records the creation of large taxpayer units, the spread of regional offices and the transition from the Central Board of Revenue to FBR. The World Bank’s own retrospective on the Tax Administration Reform Project supplies a harder finding.

Several project targets were substantially achieved, yet the completion report rated the outcome moderately unsatisfactory. One reason was that tax policy failed to support expansion of the base. An administration can install the systems it promised while the government preserves the policy choices that narrow its reach. No chairman, however technically accomplished, can audit a concession out of existence when the law grants it.

The authors recognise this problem of proof in their own assessment. They distinguish the launch of a reform from evidence that it works. They propose six months to establish baselines and a further year to pilot changes. Their conclusion nevertheless credits FBR with substantive transformation.

Consider the National Faceless Centre, which the paper identifies as a major advance because different officers handle audit, assessment and quality review. This is a sound precaution against concentrating power. Its value to a taxpayer depends on what happens when the first officer misunderstands the accounts.

Can the second see the explanation already submitted? Can the reviewer return a defective order before it creates a demand? Who has authority to close the case and tell the taxpayer why? Three officers can correct one another. They can also pass the same error down the line.

The same care is needed with the authors’ proposal to trace material transactions through an integrated digital account. Suppose a bank credit represents the transfer of money between a trader’s own accounts. A discrepancy notice may be understandable. Once the trader supplies the corresponding debit, the decisive question is whether FBR corrects the underlying record.

Cancelling one notice leaves the trader exposed to the same query in another proceeding or another year. The paper rightly calls for human review. Giving one identifiable officer responsibility for correcting the record across the relevant systems would make that safeguard worth something to the citizen.

The most consequential entry in the authors’ proposed scorecard is additional revenue attributable to better compliance. It is also the easiest to misread. Suppose, purely for illustration, that Rs. 200 billion otherwise payable in July is collected in June. The closing year gains Rs. 200 billion and the next opens with the same amount already received. Across the two periods, the timing change produces no additional revenue.

A refund left unpaid at June 30 creates a related distortion in judging performance. The Treasury holds the cash and the business finances the delay. A credible annual account would disclose collections brought forward, refunds claimed, amounts admitted, amounts disputed and claims outstanding by age. It would then be possible to ask how much an enforcement initiative actually yielded after credits, refunds and appeals.

Such an account would also give honest officers a fairer hearing. An officer who closes an unfounded inquiry promptly saves the citizen money and releases staff time for a better case. An officer who raises a large demand may earn immediate recognition even if the department later loses on the very documents available when the order was made.

Ashraf and Yousha propose measuring the quality and legality of assessments. Parliament could give that proposal practical force by asking FBR to follow a sample of assessments from the original notice through appeal to final recovery. The reasons for failure would tell a training director more than a table ranking commissioners by the value of demands raised.

The proposed sales tax zones offer an immediate opportunity to apply the paper’s own method. Before the new teams begin work, FBR could publish baseline figures for the offices concerned. How often does a business receive overlapping information requests?

How long does a refund take, including the time spent awaiting an initial decision? What proportion of additional tax assessed is ultimately collected? Comparable offices could supply a reference point as the change proceeds. Parliament, practitioners and the officers themselves would then have evidence on which to defend, revise or abandon the experiment.

Ashraf and Yousha have given FBR a more demanding set of questions than usually accompanies a restructuring announcement. Their paper is most persuasive where it leaves the verdict open. For the manufacturer who has already submitted the invoices, reform becomes tangible the day the second officer opens the file, reads the reconciliation and finds no reason to write again. FBR should be able to count that outcome too. 

Muhammad Ashraf and Muhammad Yousha, Focus on Federal Board of Revenue: Evolutionary Reorganization or Restructuring, November 2026. See “FBR Transformation Strategy”, especially “KPIs to measure actual transformation”.

Mubarak Zeb Khan, “Sales tax gets new enforcement structure to cut collection gap”, Dawn, 15 November 2026.

World Bank, Pakistan Raises Revenue Project, project appraisal document, 2019. See the discussion of lessons from the Tax Administration Reform Project.

Ashraf and Yousha, Focus on Federal Board of Revenue, “Implementation roadmap”, the assessment of the twelve transformation postulates, and “Overall conclusion”.

____________________________________________

Dr. Ikramul Haq, Advocate Supreme Court, Adjunct Faculty at Lahore University of Management Sciences (LUMS), member Advisory Board and Visiting Senior Fellow of Pakistan Institute of Development Economics (PIDE), holds an LLD in tax laws. He was full-time journalist from 1979 to 1984 with Viewpoint and Dawn. He also served Civil Services of Pakistan from 1984 to 1996.

We welcome your contributions! Submit your blogs, opinion pieces, press releases, news story pitches, and news features to opinion@minutemirror.com.pk and minutemirrormail@gmail.com
Share This Article
Dr. Ikramul Haq, Advocate Supreme Court, specialises in constitutional, corporate, media, ML/CFT related laws, IT, intellectual property, arbitration and international tax laws. He is country editor and correspondent of International Bureau of Fiscal Documentation (IBFD) and member of International Fiscal Association (IFA). He is Visiting Faculty at Lahore University of Management Sciences (LUMS) and member Advisory Board and Visiting Senior Fellow of Pakistan Institute of Development Economics (PIDE). He can be reached on Twitter @DrIkramulHaq.
Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *