Rs4.477 billion in unverified receipts: Auditors flag major irregularities in food security ministry

Nadeem Tanoli
By
Nadeem Tanoli
The writer is a journalist based in Islamabad who has been covering parliamentary affairs for the past 15 years. He also reports on health, education, environmental,...
5 Min Read

Summary

  • The objections include Rs4.924 billion linked to weak internal controls Rs2.947 billion in recoveries, Rs355.83 million in employee-related irregularities, Rs351.99 million in procurement matters and Rs136.36 million concerning bank accounts.
  • Auditors raised objections over Rs355.83 million spent on contractual staff hired during the 2020 locust emergency including entomologists, locust assistants and drivers.
  • The report also identified unspent development funds of Rs446.914 million under the National Oilseed Enhancement Programme, including Rs430.244 million retained by Punjab and Rs16.67 million not utilised or refunded by Sindh.
AI Generated Summary

ISLAMABAD: The Ministry of National Food Security and Research and its attached departments are facing audit objections involving Rs8.715 billion after federal auditors identified serious financial and administrative irregularities during the financial year 2024-25.

The audit report highlights unverified government receipts, unrecovered fees, questionable agricultural import approvals, expired pesticides, recruitment irregularities and unauthorised bank accounts.

The objections include Rs4.924 billion linked to weak internal controls Rs2.947 billion in recoveries, Rs355.83 million in employee-related irregularities, Rs351.99 million in procurement matters and Rs136.36 million concerning bank accounts.

One of the major findings concerns the Department of Plant Protection in Karachi which collected Rs4.477 billion between 2018 and 2025 through certificates issued to food, plant and pesticide importers and exporters.

However, the department failed to reconcile the receipts with bank records and the Federal Treasury Office. Auditors said they could not independently verify whether the amounts had been properly deposited into government accounts.

The department also allegedly approved 135 agricultural import conditions without mandatory pest risk assessments, scientific justification or prescribed procedures. These approvals reportedly granted exemptions from mandatory plant protection treatments to imports from Australia, the United States, Canada and Brazil.

An earlier inquiry into alleged malpractices in the methyl bromide fumigation industry had recommended corrective measures but auditors said its findings were not implemented. They also questioned why action was taken against two technical officials while the director general who approved the import conditions faced no action.

The report identified pesticides worth Rs918.98 million that had expired in government storage facilities. The stock included 300,000 litres donated by China in September 2020 for locust control which remained unused.

Auditors attributed the losses to management negligence and called for accountability and safe disposal of the expired chemicals.

The Pakistan Cotton Standards Institute also failed to recover Rs992.974 million in standardisation fees from ginning factories between 2006 and 2024. With a mandatory 100 per cent penalty, the outstanding amount reached Rs1.986 billion.

The institute additionally maintained 13 bank accounts containing Rs38.848 million without Finance Division approval. The Pakistan Veterinary Medical Council was also found operating three unauthorised accounts holding Rs97.515 million.

Auditors raised objections over Rs355.83 million spent on contractual staff hired during the 2020 locust emergency including entomologists, locust assistants and drivers.

The department reportedly failed to provide mandatory merit lists, quota records and examination results. Contracts for some entomologists continued until June 2025, despite the emergency having ended in 2020, without the required approvals.

Another Rs193.376 million spent on aircraft spare parts was declared wasteful, as the stock remained unused while most departmental aircraft were identified for disposal. The department also failed to auction 15 aircraft and related spare parts with a combined reserve value of Rs42.24 million.

Auditors further questioned Rs60.84 million spent on pesticide sprayers delivered after the locust outbreak had been controlled. Required tender documents, performance tests and demand records were reportedly missing.

The audit also highlighted encroachment on 847 square yards of government land on Karachi’s Shahrah-e-Faisal valued at Rs152.46 million. Ownership of another nine acres allotted to the department in 1964 and 1968 had not been transferred in its name.

At the National Veterinary Laboratories in Islamabad, auditors questioned the purchase of nearly 4.958 million vaccine doses for Rs58.953 million at Rs11.89 per dose, compared with an approved project estimate of Rs5. They cited conflicting delivery records, mismatched batch numbers and missing laboratory testing evidence.

The report also identified unspent development funds of Rs446.914 million under the National Oilseed Enhancement Programme, including Rs430.244 million retained by Punjab and Rs16.67 million not utilised or refunded by Sindh.

Meanwhile, a plant quarantine laboratory equipped with Chinese assistance remained non-operational despite opportunities for additional World Bank funding.

According to the report, the ministry surrendered Rs41.528 billion from its budget, bringing its final allocation down to Rs23.313 billion. Actual expenditure stood at Rs23.251 billion.

Of 56 audit objections recorded in the Public Accounts Committee compliance record, only four had been fully addressed, while 52 remained unresolved or partially addressed.

Auditors recommended recoveries, investigations, accountability and corrective measures. The report also noted that management had failed to respond to several major objections before its finalisation.

We welcome your contributions! Submit your blogs, opinion pieces, press releases, news story pitches, and news features to opinion@minutemirror.com.pk and minutemirrormail@gmail.com
Share This Article
The writer is a journalist based in Islamabad who has been covering parliamentary affairs for the past 15 years. He also reports on health, education, environmental, and human rights issues. He can be reached at nadeemumer6@gmail.com.
Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *